A 12-year veteran and a career-long Brown, guard Joel Bitonio is scheduled to become a free agent next month. Before Bitonio signs with the Browns or anyone else, he’ll have to decide whether to play in 2026.
With Bitonio mulling retirement, he and the Browns agreed to push back the void date on his contract until the end of the league year in March, Jason Lloyd of The Athletic reports. The original void deadline for Bitonio was Feb. 16. Had Bitonio’s contract voided, it would have stuck the Browns with a $23MM dead cap charge.
This is the third straight offseason in which Bitonio has considered retirement, but he hung around long enough to finish a three-year, $48MM extension. That was money well spent for Cleveland, which stole Bitonio in the second round of the 2014 draft. The 34-year-old Nevada product is now a seven-time Pro Bowler and a two-time first-team All-Pro.
Bitonio’s streak of seven straight Pro Bowls ended in 2025, but he remained a constant presence on an injury-ravaged line. He was the only member of the Browns’ front five to start all 17 games, the ninth full campaign of his decorated career. Bitonio was on the field for a team-high 99.72% of offensive snaps. As Pro Football Focus’ 21st-ranked guard among 79 qualfiiers, he remained a rare bright spot on a struggling offense.
While the Browns were able to count on Bitonio yet again, fellow starting linemen Dawand Jones, Ethan Pocic, Wyatt Teller and Jack Conklin all missed between four and 14 games. The injuries along the line negatively contributed to a 5-12 season and a 30th-place ranking in total offense for the Browns. Now, with Bitonio, Pocic (coming off a December Achilles tear) and Teller nearing free agency, the Browns are continuing to deal with uncertainty up front.
Trade him to a contender. Give him a chance at a title run for a year before he calls it quits. The Browns owe him that.