Earlier this month, the Panthers signed quarterback and former first-round pick Kenny Pickett. That transaction seemed to point Andy Dalton out of Charlotte, and indeed, the club dealt the veteran passer to the Eagles shortly after the Pickett signing.
According to Panthers vice president of football operations Brandt Tilis (via ESPN’s David Newton), the motivation behind the QB room shakeup was simple: the team wanted Pickett to work as starter Bryce Young’s backup in 2026, and Dalton – who had served as Young’s backup over the past three seasons – still wants to compete for a QB2 opportunity. Philadelphia offers such an opportunity, and a trade was consummated.
The guaranteed money in Pickett’s Carolina contract ($4MM) is actually identical to what Dalton is due to earn in the last year of his current deal ($3.9MM base salary plus $100K workout bonus). Clearly, the Pickett-for-Dalton switch was not motivated by finances and was driven instead by other factors.
Getting younger is one such factor, but there could also be a belief in Pickett’s upside at play here. Although the Panthers finished the 2025 regular season with an 8-9 record, that was good enough to win the NFC South, and Carolina nearly toppled the Rams in the wildcard round of the playoffs. As such, if there were not a certain amount of faith in Pickett, it would have made sense for a team that has designs on another postseason run to keep the more established Dalton rather than replace him with a player who has not yet found much success at the professional level.
On the other hand, Dalton has posted a 1-6 record as a starter during his Carolina tenure, along with an 84.5 quarterback rating. Those underwhelming figures could have led Panthers brass to believe Pickett at least will be no worse than Dalton if he is pressed into action, and since Pickett – the No. 20 overall pick of the 2022 draft – is nearly 11 years younger than his 38-year-old predecessor, there still may be another level for him to unlock.
At present, there are no other signal-callers on the Panthers’ depth chart, while the Eagles are still rostering Tanner McKee. A sixth-round pick in 2023, McKee has started just two games in his NFL career, though he has shown enough promise to pop up in trade rumors concerning QB-needy clubs. For now, he and Dalton are poised to battle for the backup job behind Jalen Hurts, but ever-opportunistic GM Howie Roseman has a highly-experienced insurance policy in Dalton should he receive an acceptable offer for McKee.
that reasoning doesn’t make sense to me. They both wanted the same thing, Pickett was looked at as Bryce Young’s primary backup, vs, Dalton wanted a chance to compete for QB2. What’s the difference?
It seems they just wanted Pickett more than Dalton. Youth and (perhaps) upside.
I agree. While Dalton is pushing 40, I’d still rather have him if I need a backup to start a few games. Pickett has shown absolutely nothing (still yet to ever throw multiple touchdowns in a single game) and is by no means young (28 next year).