APRIL 20: A trade involving Thibodeaux is now less likely given the Lawrence blockbuster, Ian Rapoport of NFL Network reports. Trade calls have indeed taken place recently, but a strong enough offer has yet to be presented. The Athletic’s Dan Duggan confirms the Giants will not accept a Day 3 pick to move on from Thibodeaux, so he may remain in the fold through at least the draft.
APRIL 18: Kayvon Thibodeaux‘s name has frequently been mentioned in trade speculation, and the draft looms as a logical window for a deal to be worked out in his case. The Giants will be worth monitoring as they weigh their options on the Thibodeaux front.
It was reported in March that the Giants’ preference would be to move on in this case, and it became clear at the Combine the team would be open to fielding offers. No Thibodeaux swap was worked out ahead of the 2025 trade deadline. New York could elect to keep him in the fold to play out his fifth-year option, but a trade remains something to watch for over the coming days.
Casino.com’s Jason La Canfora writes it would be “quite surprising” if Thibodeaux were to still be with the Giants by the end of next week’s draft. A general manager he spoke with said New York hopes to secure a third-round pick in a trade but would be willing to accept an offer of a fourth-rounder. Any return in that range would of course represent a highly underwhelming end to the former No. 5 selection’s time as a Giant.
Thibodeaux has started all 55 of his combined regular and postseason appearances for New York, but his production and playing time has fluctuated across his four NFL seasons. 2025 saw his snap share drop to a career-low 72%, and the Oregon product’s 2.5 sacks were also a personal low. Thibodeaux has played a full campaign only once, and the Giants have a starting edge rush tandem in the form of Brian Burns and Abdul Carter for 2026 and beyond.
Those factors help explain New York’s aversion to a long-term Thibodeaux contract but they will also limit his trade value. The 25-year-old is owed $14.75MM for next season, making him an expensive rental option. An acquiring team could attempt to work out an extension, but doing so could be challenging given Thibodeaux’s career arc to date. Still, an edge rusher at his age could be an intriguing buy-low target for any number of suitors.
The Giants are currently set to experience a wide gap between their second pick (No. 37) and third one (No. 105). Acquiring a third-round selection would help bridge that divide and provide additional draft capital to improve a defense in need of upgrades with or without Dexter Lawrence in the fold.
Do the Bengals have the cap space for him too?
If he’s only worth a 4th or 5th this is horrible asset management. Giants are a joke
they should just keep him at that point, a 5th would be a complete waste for a player that talented
He’s solid but not spectacular and will be a free agent at the end of the season, but I am with the Giants- I would need a 3rd to trade him, or no deal.
Yeah, Id rather keep him in the rotation than accept a 4th or 5th
It probably was a mistake Schoen made picking Tibs to begin with given his penchant for taking plays off in college, but trading him now for anything less than 3rd round value would be two wrongs not making a right……He’s been relatively solid outside of the injuries he’s had….If Carter or Burns goes down due to injury, or from a rotational standpoint, isn’t it up to the current coaching staff to “coach him up” ?
The deal less likely….because he can play the inside? Smh
Who says No? Bills and Giants swap WR Keon Coleman for Giants Edge Kayvon Thibadeaux? Harbaugh I’m sure remembers Keon’s big game against the Ravens to open last season.
Miami sitting on 4 3rd rounders