With the Jaguars extending Evan Engram on Sunday, this year’s franchise tag period is now down to the three running backs. Of those three situations, Tony Pollard‘s Cowboys negotiations have generated the fewest headlines. There might be a good reason for that.
Pollard remains expected to play this season on the $10.1MM tag. He and the Cowboys have until 3pm CT to hammer out an agreement, but the team may not have been all that serious about an extension at this time. Talks between Pollard and the Cowboys are not believed to have been substantive this offseason, NFL.com’s Jane Slater tweets.
Whereas Saquon Barkley and Josh Jacobs have been starters throughout their respective careers, Pollard has operated as a high-end change-of-pace option in Dallas. The dual-threat back did earn his first Pro Bowl nod last season, but Ezekiel Elliott still hovered as the team’s starter. Both players scored 12 touchdowns, though Pollard has been the Cowboys’ more explosive back for some time. Still, Elliott is in play to return on a lower-cost deal. The Cowboys also may want to see how Pollard responds to a heavier workload before making a multiyear commitment.
The team has not been shy about leaving franchise tag numbers on its payroll past the mid-July deadline. DeMarcus Lawrence played on the tag in 2018, with Dak Prescott following suit in 2020. Dalton Schultz played on the tag last year, while defensive end Anthony Spencer played two seasons on the tag (2012 and 2013) before re-signing with the team the following year. With the running back tag checking in as this year’s second-lowest number — above just the kicker/punter figure — Pollard playing at $10.1MM will not be as damaging as Prescott’s tag number staying on the Cowboys’ cap sheet three years ago.
The Cowboys waded into the deep waters of the RB market in 2019, extending Elliott despite two years of team control left. Elliott’s six-year, $90MM extension did not work out for the Cowboys, who saw their bellcow back decline while attached to the league’s second-most lucrative running back deal. This opened the door for Pollard, a fourth-round find. Pollard has logged just 510 carries since the Cowboys drafted him out of Memphis; Elliott had totaled 868 in just three seasons. Of the three franchise-tagged backs this year, Pollard’s workload points to him remaining in his prime the longest.
Pollard signed his franchise tender in late March; this money represents a nice payday for a player who has spent much of his career as a backup. The 26-year-old back, however, is missing out on a key offseason to cash in. Running back value has endured several hits this offseason, and Pollard could certainly have scored more than $10.1MM guaranteed were he permitted to hit the open market in March. The fifth-year back is also rehabbing a broken leg and high ankle sprain suffered in the Cowboys’ divisional-round loss.
This sets up a critical season for the Day 3 success story. The Cowboys took care of Lawrence and Prescott in the years after their seasons on the tag. With running back careers shorter compared to standouts at other positions, a season on the tag stands to affect Pollard’s earning potential more than it did Lawrence or Prescott’s. But teams have had the option of keeping their top free agent off the market via the tag since 1993. Pollard will not be the first player to see his earning power affected by it.