In 2024, the Bills had neither Micah Hyde nor Jordan Poyer on the field at the safety position. The former spent the campaign on the practice squad and has since retired, while the latter played in Miami upon being released last March. 
Poyer remains on the market well past the draft, and a second season with the Dolphins should not be expected. The 34-year-old knows his career is nearing an end, but he does not intend to join Hyde in retirement at this point. Poyer made it clear during an appearance on Good Morning Football he is looking to play in 2025.
“I’m in a place right now where I played 12 years, extremely thankful and blessed to have played the game for such a long time,” Poyer said (via NFL.com). “Would I like to play again? Absolutely. Whatever that looks like… It’d be dope, it’d be ideal to have a fantasy ending and be able to retire a Bill, but who knows? I’m just being an open book right now, really enjoying life for what it is.”
Poyer began his Buffalo tenure in 2017, and he remained a full-time starter with the team for seven years. The tandem which was in place with Hyde was among the league’s best for a time, but Buffalo went in a different direction in 2024. Hyde was replaced in the starting lineup while Poyer was released. That led to an intra-AFC East deal, but it did not yield the desired result. The former seventh-rounder was held without an interception for the second straight year on a Dolphins team which fell short of the postseason.
Between that and his age, Poyer will be hard-pressed to generate a notable market for his services in 2025. Buffalo has veterans Taylor Rapp and Damar Hamlin still in place along with 2024 second-rounder Cole Bishop. The Bills’ most recent draft leaned heavily on defense, but it did not include any new safeties being brought in. A low-cost deal over one year would likely be sufficient to bring about a reunion in this case, but Buffalo sits second-last in the league with only $1.77MM in cap space at the moment.
Fellow veteran safeties Justin Simmons and Julian Blackmon are also on the market at this point. They may have new deals in place before Poyer does, whether that takes the form of another Bills pact or one sending him to another team during the waning stages of his career.
Love that guy – but no.
This doesn’t make sense.