Although Nolan Smith is coming off a down season, he remains a key part of the Eagles’ defense. The team acquired Jonathan Greenard from the Vikings during the draft, extending the Pro Bowl edge rusher, but Smith is slated to remain on the team’s payroll for two more seasons.
The Eagles are exercising Smith’s fifth-year option, ESPN.com’s Jeremy Fowler reports. This will fully guarantee his 2027 salary. Smith is expected to be classified as a linebacker, per Fowler and OverTheCap. He is eligible for the bottom-tier option figure; for linebackers, that comes out to $13.75MM.
[RELATED: 2027 NFL Fifth-Year Option Tracker]
Situations like this have led to disagreements on edge rushers’ positions. This year, the defensive end position’s fourth-tier option number checks in at $14.48MM. Teams have regularly used the linebacker tag on 3-4 OLBs, even though the players spend more time rushing as a defensive end in sub-packages. Smith saw minimal playing time as a rookie in 2023 but moved to a regular role in 2024. A five-game injury absence limited his development last season.
The 2023 season marked the second and final campaign featuring Josh Sweat and Haason Reddick co-anchoring Philly’s pass rush. The Eagles traded Reddick to the Jets and gave Sweat a pay cut in 2024, eyeing a bigger role for Smith. After sitting behind the two veterans in 2023, Smith joined Sweat as a regular. He moved into Philly’s starting lineup around midseason and finished with 6.5 sacks. As Sweat upped his free agency stock with a solid season to anchor the Eagles’ edge rush during a Super Bowl-winning season, Smith was a key playoff contributor after registering four postseason sacks.
Smith, 25, has not necessarily justified his first-round draft slot just yet. He finished last season with just three sacks and one tackle for loss. Asked to be the Eagles’ top edge rusher entering the season — after Brandon Graham‘s retirement and Sweat’s Cardinals defection — Smith did not impress in that role and suffered a triceps strain in September. The undersized pass rusher returned from IR in Week 9 and did finish the season with 11 QB hits, but Greenard now serves as the Eagles’ EDGE linchpin.
Greenard essentially replaces Jaelan Phillips, whom the Eagles tried to re-sign. A four-year, $120MM Panthers contract lured the 2025 trade pickup away from Pennsylvania, but Greenard is now on a 4/100 deal that runs through the 2029 season. Smith may be more qualified for an OLB2-type role, and Greenard is positioned to be the team’s top outside ‘backer next season. The Eagles also signed Arnold Ebiketie from the Falcons last month, and two years remain on Jalyx Hunt‘s third-round contract (the unretired Graham is also interested in playing a 17th season). Hunt outplayed Smith in 2025, recording 6.5 sacks and a team-high 24 QB hits. It will be interesting to see how the Eagles divide playing time between their Greenard sidekicks in 2026.
The Eagles also picked up Jalen Carter‘s fifth-year option today, and Smith’s ex-Georgia teammate is viewed as an extension candidate. Carter should be expected to take precedence, the Philadelphia Inquirer’s Jeff McLane notes. Considering Carter’s two Pro Bowl nods and place as an upper-crust defensive tackle, that is unsurprising.
It would surprise a bit if Smith were viewed as a clear-cut extension candidate, considering he did not build on his impressive 2024. The Eagles, though, now have more time to observe Smith in Vic Fangio‘s defense. This option decision locks him down for two more years. Philly will have a clearer picture of what a second Smith contract would look like after the 2026 campaign.
I like Nolan a lot. I think he adds to the defense well but if today was the deadline I’d let him walk unless he took a team friendly deal. But some team will overpay for him most likely.
In a way him not fighting over the OLB vs DE 5th year option distinction is him taking a team friendly deal
I meant at extension time.
I think that will work itself out this season. If he bounces back and produces he will get paid and the Eagles will be happy to do it. If he doesn’t, then he’s gone.
Yeah that is either going to look really good, or really bad with no middle ground.
They’ve done studies, you know. 60% of the time, it works every time
There’s a ton of middle ground. A ton.
Hunt is the guy, not Smith.
Hunt was the guy everybody was talking about leading up to last year, not Smith.
Smith has never been a true pass rusher the way Hunt is. He’s a guy with pretty good instincts who makes impact plays but he’s not the guy pushing the pile or giving opposing tackles fits. He’s more like an opportunistic clean up player. He can set the edge pretty well and make plays in space but he’s not gonna be the main one generating pressure.
Given that, I really wouldn’t call last year a down year for him. I don’t see him as a double digit sack guy unless he’s playing opposite a Parsons/Myles/TJ/Hutch/Crosby level pass rusher. I don’t even know that he’d get double digit sacks in that situation.