Having undergone core muscle surgery earlier this month, Bengals defensive end Trey Hendrickson will not return in 2025. Hendrickson hasn’t taken the field since a Week 8 loss to the Jets. With a trip to free agency looming in the offseason, Hendrickson has likely played his last game with the organization, according to Albert Breer of SI.com.
Hendrickson spent the first four seasons of his career with the Saints before exiting in free agency for the Bengals’ four-year, $60MM offer March 2021. The former third-round pick from Florida Atlantic scored that payday on the heels of a breakout season in which he tallied 13.5 sacks. Looking back, that was the beginning of a years-long run of elite production.
Since leaving New Orleans for Cincinnati, Hendrickson has collected 61 sacks – including a league-best 35 from 2023-24 – in 72 games. Hendrickson made the Pro Bowl in each of his first four years as a Bengal. He also helped the Bengals to a pair of AFC title games and a Super Bowl appearance in his first two years in their uniform.
The Bengals awarded Hendrickson a one-year extension entering 2023, keeping him under wraps through this season, but that wasn’t the last transaction between the two. Hendrickson sought a new multiyear pact after last season, though he reportedly turned down a three-year, $95MM offer. The Bengals’ rejected proposal did not include any guaranteed money after the first year of the deal.
After a drawn-out battle, the Bengals and Hendrickson finally agreed to a revised contract for this season in late August. Hendrickson had been in line to earn $16MM, but Cincinnati almost doubled that amount in raising his salary to $30MM. Frustration increased on both sides during negotiations, per Breer. The Bengals were sick of the “drama” surrounding Hendrickson, who was “tired of having to fight for a contract correction,” Breer writes.
With Hendrickson having made his final appearance of the season on Oct. 26, it’s fair to say the Bengals’ investment didn’t turn out as hoped. The 31-year-old remained a formidable pass-rushing presence with 23 pressures and four sacks in seven games, but his long-term absence has contributed to a miserable campaign for the Bengals. At 4-10, they’re assured of missing the playoffs for the third year in a row.
Regardless of whether de facto general manager Duke Tobin stays in place, deciding how to proceed with Hendrickson will again be a key offseason task for the organization. If a multiyear arrangement isn’t in store, the Bengals could slap the $35MM franchise tag on Hendrickson and either keep him for another season or flip him elsewhere. Hendrickson drew plenty of interest leading up to the Nov. 4 trade deadline, but nobody bit on the Bengals’ asking price of a second-round pick. He’s still a Bengal a month and a half later, though it appears their relationship is nearing an end.