With a trip to free agency looming, longtime Browns tight end David Njoku took to Instagram on Feb. 9 to say goodbye to Cleveland. Another Browns staple, pending free agent guard Wyatt Teller, did the same on Wednesday (via Mike Garafolo of NFL Network).
As part of a lengthy letter, Teller wrote: “I wish things were different and this is hard to put into words. When Buffalo traded me to Cleveland seven years ago, I never could have imagined how much this city would mean to me. Ultimately, the Browns took a chance on me that changed the trajectory of my life forever … While we are excited and look forward to what the future holds, Cleveland will always have a special place in our hearts.”
Teller joined the Bills as a fifth-round pick out of Virginia Tech in 2018, but they moved on despite seeing him start in seven of eight appearances as a rookie.
Shortly before the start of the 2019 season, the Bills traded Teller and a 2021 seventh-rounder to the Browns for a fifth- and sixth-rounder in 2020. It proved to be a great trade for then-Browns general manager John Dorsey, though he ended up losing his job after a 6-10 campaign.
A left guard in Buffalo, Teller turned into a stalwart on the right side in Cleveland. After coming off the bench in six of 15 games in 2019, he became a full-time starter the next year. The 31-year-old has since gone to three Pro Bowls and earned second-team All-Pro honors twice.
Teller logged his second 17-game season in 2023, but he followed that up with back-to-back years with stints on injured reserve. He missed four games with an MCL sprain in 2024 and then sat out four more with a calf injury last season. Pro Football Focus ranked the banged-up Teller a middling 39th among 79 qualifying guards in 2025, but his track record suggests he’ll land the second lucrative contract of his career soon.
Teller just wrapped up the four-year, $56.8MM extension he signed in 2021. As of last September, there was reportedly a decent chance of a new deal coming together with the Browns. Five months later, it appears the two will go in different directions.
It is obvious the Browns’ offensive line will look much different next season. Not only is Teller on his way out, but their other top guard, Joel Bitonio, is unsigned and considering retirement. Center Ethan Pocic, tackles Jack Conklin and Cam Robinson, and backup guard Teven Jenkins are also scheduled to reach the open market in March.
Jaguars. Texans. Broncos. Niners. Steelers
Lions!!!
Browns desperately need linemen, but they’re likely going to rebuild from the ground up, at least until they can clear some money off the books. Teller was an absolute unit for three consecutive years, until he started getting banged up. Hopefully he can get healthy and succeed elsewhere.