Nathan Peterman is best known for some rough performances as a Bills starter, but the veteran quarterback has managed a long career as a reserve option. The experienced quarterback has secured another opportunity.
Although Peterman was out of the NFL last season, 9News’ Mike Klis notes he secured a tryout at the Broncos’ rookie minicamp this weekend. The Broncos return their top three QBs from 2025, having re-signed third-stringer Sam Ehlinger, but recent Bo Nix news points to Denver needing a third healthy option for its offseason program.
Nix underwent a follow-up ankle procedure recently and likely will not be full go until training camp. Limited OTAs participation appears on tap for Denver’s starter, putting Jarrett Stidham in position to take first-team reps in spring workouts. Peterman, 32, was last with the Falcons, who carried him on their practice squad throughout the 2024 season.
The 2017 fifth-round pick has been with five teams in his career. The Raiders, Bears and Saints also rostered him at points. Sean Payton was not in New Orleans during Peterman’s cameo with the team (during the 2024 offseason). The Broncos have not officially announced their UDFA class, but no QBs are believed to be part of that group. Thus, Peterman will have a chance to work at the team’s rookie camp soon.
Peterman has five career starts; just one has come since his Buffalo tenure ended in 2018. He spent three-plus seasons with the Raiders; that covered most of Jon Gruden‘s second HC stay with the team and the Rich Bisaccia interim stint. The Bears added Peterman in 2022 and used him at a rather key point on their timeline. Chicago sat Justin Fields for Week 18 of the 2022 season, and the Peterman start resulted in a loss that clinched Chicago the No. 1 overall pick — which the team dealt to Carolina in the Bryce Young swap. Peterman returned to the Bears in 2023 but caught on with the Falcons the following year.
The Broncos have carried two QBs on their active roster, for the most part, during Payton’s tenure. But Nix’s ankle issue and Ehlinger’s $1MM guarantee creates a natural assumption they will go with three active-roster passers in 2026. A fourth QB as a practice squad stash may be overkill, but that would appear Peterman’s ceiling if he is to stick with the team for offseason work. This also may merely be for the rookie camp, with the Denver Gazette’s Chris Tomasson noting the team had been targeting a veteran QB to throw passes to rookies at that multiday gathering. It nonetheless represents an opportunity for a player who has crafted a longer-than-expected career than his career 4:13 TD-INT ratio would suggest.

Nathan Peterman and Josh Johnson will be great NFL coaches some day.
This guy won’t quit lol
Dude must have an amazing personality.
Nathan “Five Picks” Peterman.
I would like to book a tryout too