PFR Originals: 4/3/16 – 4/10/16
The original content and analysis produced by the PFR staff during the past week:
- With less than three weeks remaining until the draft begins, Rob DiRe published the first edition of PFR’s 2016 Mock Draft. As Rob writes, this mock draft is a little different than the industry consensus, especially at the top of the first round, where the Titans and Browns are projected to select Jalen Ramsey and Myles Jack, respectively.
- Zach Links rounded up the best of the football blogs in the latest edition of Pigskin Links.
PFR Originals: 3/13/16 – 3/20/16
The original content and analysis produced by the PFR staff during the past week:
- Now that the dust has cleared, Luke Adams has taken several overviews of the free agent period and all its implications. Last Monday, Luke looked at where things stood from a 10,000-foot view, including going over the contracts of PFR’s top free agents and taking a peek at the best remaining free agents.
- Today, with even more free agents having been signed, Luke detailed the best players still on the board, looking at the best available free agents on both offense and defense.
- Perhaps the most interesting contract signed this offseason has been left tackle Russell Okung‘s deal with the Broncos, which Okung negotiated himself. The pact contains no guaranteed money, and features an option that would trigger the four additional years after 2016. Luke has the full breakdown of the contract, as well as a look at the best- and worst-case scenarios for Okung.
- We posted our list of 2016 NFL Trades, which will be updated throughout the season until the fall trade deadline.
- Zach Links rounded up the best of the football blogs in the latest edition of Pigskin Links.
Notable Free Agents Still Available: Defense
We’re about a week and a half into the 2016 league year, and most of the top free agents have signed – or at least agreed to – new contracts. With teams shifting their focus to draft preparation for the next several weeks, the height of this year’s free agent period is now behind us, but that doesn’t mean there aren’t still many players available who will land new deals of their own in the coming weeks and months.
Earlier today, with the help of our top 50 list of free agents, and our complete breakdown of all the free agents still available, we examined some of the top free agents still available on offense. We’ll shift our focus to the other side of the ball now, and break down of some of the most notable players at each defensive position who are still not under contract.
There’s arguably no more talented player currently on the free agent market than Greg Hardy, who finds himself in a similar situation to the one he was in a year ago. In 2015, Hardy’s off-field troubles scared most teams away, but the Cowboys ultimately signed him to an incentive-laden deal that minimized the risk for the team.
If Hardy had kept his head down, been on his best behavior, and avoided making headlines in Dallas, teams would likely be more willing to bet on him this time around. Instead, he once again created problems both off the field and on the Cowboys’ sideline, as more details of his domestic violence incident surfaced. Ultimately, with many clubs apparently still unconvinced that Hardy’s talent makes him worth the risk, the standout defensive end may have to settle for another one-year, prove-it deal.
Hardy isn’t the only 4-3 defensive end of interest on the board, but most of the others are part-time rotational players. Jason Jones, Chris Clemons, and Jeremy Mincey are among the more appealing options in the group.
Teams in the market for a 3-4 outside linebacker won’t find much help on the free agent market. The most noteworthy names available are veterans who are in their mid-30s, such as Dwight Freeney, Jason Babin, and Calvin Pace.
Mike Neal has some appeal, and Courtney Upshaw has flashed a little promise during his years in Baltimore, but neither player will be a difference-making pass rusher. The only player who fits that bill is Aldon Smith, and he’ll be serving a suspension until at least November.
Interior defensive line:
Muhammad Wilkerson is technically still a free agent, but his franchise tag means he won’t be signing an offer sheet with another club — if any team were willing to give up the requisite two first-round picks to sign Wilkerson, they’d simply work out a trade with the Jets for a lesser package instead.
Of the unrestricted free agents, Nick Fairley is probably the top option available. The Saints, Eagles, and Jets have been cited as potential suitors for Fairley, who reportedly made a visit to New Orleans this past week. A part-time contributor, Fairley has picked up just 1.5 sacks in his past two seasons for the Lions and Rams, but he continues to earn solid grades from Pro Football Focus as both a run defender and pass rusher.
While the interior defensive line market probably lacks impact players at the moment, there’s no shortage of depth. If you’re looking for a nose tackle, a player like Terrance Knighton or Sammie Lee Hill may have some appeal. Teams in the market for a 3-4 defensive end could kick the tires on veterans like Stephen Bowen, Chris Canty, Jared Crick, and Mike DeVito.
There are plenty of former Pro Bowlers still available in free agency, including Randy Starks, Kevin Williams, Henry Melton, Jason Hatcher, and Antonio Smith. And we haven’t even mentioned solid veterans like C.J. Mosley, Kyle Love, Cullen Jenkins, Tony McDaniel, Dwan Edwards, Barry Cofield, Nick Hayden, and C.J. Wilson.
One problem for all these veteran free agents? Teams in need of some help on the defensive line may be looking ahead to the draft, where defensive tackle is viewed as perhaps the deepest position class of 2016. Some of these free agents will find new homes before then, but many may have to wait until after the draft, at which point clubs who missed out on targets on draft day may circle back and sign a veteran.
Linebacker:
Teams in search of a short-term stop gap at inside linebacker still have some options. Karlos Dansby, DeMeco Ryans, Curtis Lofton, and Erin Henderson are among the veterans who can still contribute. David Hawthorne, Donald Butler, Kavell Conner, Philip Wheeler, and Joe Mays also have plenty of career starts on their NFL résumés, but aren’t coming off particularly strong seasons, so they’re nothing more than depth options at this point.
Elsewhere, Zach Brown, Craig Robertson, and O’Brien Schofield are among the more intriguing free agent linebackers on the market. All three players are in their 20s and possess some versatility, though they’d probably be best suited as outside linebackers in a 4-3 scheme. Schofield has picked up 15.5 career sacks, while Brown and Robertson have each totaled six career interceptions.
Chad Greenway, Danny Lansanah, Justin Durant, Bruce Carter, and Spencer Paysinger round out the non-rush linebackers of note.
The cornerback market has been somewhat slow to develop this month, with a handful of players we viewed as top-10 free agents at the position still available. Patrick Robinson and Leon Hall are two solid veterans capable of a starting job — both players ranked as top-35 corners in 2015 (out of 111 qualified players), per Pro Football Focus. And both players have been linked to the Cowboys.
Brandon Boykin wasn’t far behind Robinson and Hall, ranking 38th in PFF’s grades, despite not seeing significant playing time in Pittsburgh until late in the season. Boykin has always shown flashes of upside, particularly in his six-interception 2013 campaign, but has never really gotten the opportunity to be a full-time player — he has just seven career starts. He’s still just 25 years old, so it’s a little surprising he hasn’t been snatched up yet.
While there are plenty of other cornerbacks out there who could compete for No. 3 or No. 4 spots on teams’ depth charts, there aren’t really any others you’d feel comfortable penciling in as your No. 2. Antonio Cromartie, Brandon Browner, and Cortland Finnegan all saw extensive playing time in 2015, but their best days are probably behind them, barring surprise bounce-back seasons.
Jerraud Powers, Sterling Moore, and Charles Tillman are other names worth monitoring.
As is the case at cornerback, the safety position features some players worthy of NFL starting jobs. Reggie Nelson is one — he’s coming off a strong season in Cincinnati, and while his age (33 in September) may have prevented him from landing a big-money deal, I’m surprised Nelson has yet to sign anywhere.
Rashad Johnson was a first-time starter in Arizona for the second consecutive season, and wasn’t a weak link in the Cardinals’ secondary. Husain Abdullah, meanwhile, was part of a stacked group of safeties in Kansas City that included Eric Berry, Ron Parker, and Tyvon Branch, so he wasn’t a starter in 2015, but he has shown in the past that he’s capable of stepping in when needed.
Two of the most talented safeties currently on the free agent market may not end up signing anywhere this offseason, with Walter Thurmond contemplating retirement and Will Hill facing a 10-game suspension. Thurmond made the transition from cornerback in 2015, and had a pretty impressive first year at safety, while Hill looked like one of the league’s top defensive backs during the first half of the season.
Teams in need of a safety may also consider veterans such as Will Allen, Quintin Demps, William Moore, James Ihedigbo, Louis Delmas, and Roman Harper.
Photos courtesy of USA Today Sports Images.
Notable Free Agents Still Available: Offense
We’re about a week and a half into the 2016 league year, and most of the top free agents have signed – or at least agreed to – new contracts. With teams shifting their focus to draft preparation for the next several weeks, the height of this year’s free agent period is now behind us, but that doesn’t mean there aren’t still many players available who will land new deals of their own in the coming weeks and months.
With the help of our top 50 list of free agents, and our complete breakdown of all the free agents still available, here’s a breakdown of some of the most notable players at each offensive position who are still not under contract.
Somewhat surprisingly, Ryan Fitzpatrick remains unsigned, having been unable to find common ground with the Jets or to generate a ton of interest from other teams. Neither the Jets nor other potential suitors, such as the Broncos, are likely to get into a bidding war for Fitzpatrick, who doesn’t want to settle for a below-market deal after seeing how guys like Kirk Cousins, Brock Osweiler, and Sam Bradford did this month. I’d expect the veteran to ultimately re-up with the Jets before offseason workouts get underway.
Elsewhere, Robert Griffin III and Johnny Manziel are among the young, once-promising quarterbacks who have been released recently, but Manziel, at least, likely won’t sign anywhere until he commits to making some changes in his personal life.
Tarvaris Jackson, Michael Vick, and Brandon Weeden are a few of the probable backups still available, while Case Keenum and Matt McGloin are technically still free agents as well, but won’t receive much interest due to the RFA tenders – and draft pick compensation – attached to them.
Running back:
Alfred Morris is the top running back still on the board, and the relative lack of interest in him is perhaps a sign that teams were put off by the drop-off in his 2015 production. He has a visit with the Cowboys lined up, but it doesn’t look like he’ll land the sort of lucrative, multiyear deal that fellow free agent backs like Chris Ivory and Lamar Miller did.
There are several recognizable names out there on the running back market, but many are either on the wrong side of 30 or will turn 30 later this year, so clubs will have to determine how much those players have left in the tank — Joique Bell, LeGarrette Blount, Reggie Bush, Tim Hightower, Fred Jackson, and Pierre Thomas are among the free agents who fit that bill.
One of the younger backs still available is 24-year-old Ronnie Hillman, who is coming off a career year (863 yards, seven touchdowns, 4.2 ypc). The Broncos brought back Hillman’s backfield mate C.J. Anderson on a four-year, $18MM contract, so it’ll be interesting to see whether Denver has room to re-sign Hillman as well.
Arian Foster and Stevan Ridley are two players worth mentioning as well, though their health will be a key consideration for suitors. Foster is coming off a torn Achilles and turns 30 this August, so I imagine teams will be reluctant to add him until he shows he’s close to a full recovery. Ridley, meanwhile, is another year removed from a devastating ACL/MCL tear, so he may have more potential for 2016 than he showed in 2015.
Top options like Marvin Jones, Travis Benjamin, Mohamed Sanu, and Rishard Matthews were snatched up in the early days of free agency, but plenty of intriguing names remain. The most intriguing one is Rueben Randle, who turns 25 this month and has averaged 64 receptions and 868 yards in his last two seasons. While Randle’s youth and talent are appealing, the Giants reportedly questioned his work ethic and his “desire to be great.” One has to imagine those factors are playing a part in the fact that he’s still unsigned, though he reportedly paid a visit to the Rams.
Outside of Randle, the most noteworthy free agent wideouts still in their 20s are players with question marks, such as Hakeem Nicks, Percy Harvin, Brandon LaFell, and Riley Cooper. Nicks and Harvin certainly have plenty of upside, but it has been a while since they’ve had really strong seasons, and it’s looking increasingly unlikely that they’ll ever regain that form.
Currently, the market for receivers is dominated by big-name veterans. Anquan Boldin and James Jones lead the pack as two players coming off strong seasons, who saw their contracts expire rather than having them terminated. Veterans who have been cut in recent weeks include Dwayne Bowe, Marques Colston, Greg Jennings, Andre Johnson, and Roddy White.
Tight end:
The tight end ranks have thinned out considerably in the first week and a half of free agency, but there are still some veteran pass catchers out there for teams in the market for a player who fits that mold. Jared Cook is probably the most appealing option, but guys like Owen Daniels, Vernon Davis, and Scott Chandler should also draw some interest. Cook has met with the Packers, while Davis visited Washington.
If teams are seeking out a blocking option instead, there are several of those worth targeting as well. Clay Harbor and John Phillips, for instance, each made their way into our top 15 list for tight ends when free agency began earlier this month, and have yet to find new NFL homes.
Two offensive tackles from our top 15 are still available, and both players are veterans with troublesome injury histories. I still expect Will Beatty and former first overall pick Jake Long to land deals at some point, but in a market where even younger tackles like Russell Okung and Kelvin Beachum were forced to settle for team-friendly deals due to health concerns, I can’t imagine Beatty or Long finding a huge payday. Nate Chandler, Jason Fox, and Don Barclay are among the other UFA tackles available.
At guard, the pattern is somewhat similar. Jahri Evans, Willie Colon, Chris Chester, Ben Grubbs, Todd Herremans, Kraig Urbik, and Manuel Ramirez are all in their 30s, and for some of them, health issues may keep them on the market for a while yet. However, there are still some intriguing options in that group and elsewhere. Jon Asamoah, Louis Vasquez, and Geoff Schwartz also remain in play.
Finally, the center market wasn’t deep when free agency began, and with Ben Jones having signed quickly, it looks even thinner now. But Stefen Wisniewski should appeal to clubs, having been a steady presence in the middle of the line for the Raiders and Jaguars in recent years. J.D. Walton, Lyle Sendlein, Will Montgomery, and Ryan Wendell are among the other centers with extensive starting experience within the last couple seasons.
Photos courtesy of USA Today Sports Images.
Examining Russell Okung’s Self-Negotiated Contract
Russell Okung‘s new five-year deal with the Broncos has been one of the most-discussed free agent contracts during the second week of the 2016 league year, and there are a number of reasons why it has been such a topic of interest.
If Okung plays out the entire contract, it would be worth well over $50MM, making it one of the most valuable overall deals in 2016 free agency, and we rarely see contracts that big signed more than a week into the league year. Additionally, the structure is somewhat unique, since it’s essentially a one-year pact with a four-year option.
Ultimately though, the interest in Okung’s deal comes down to two factors:
- It features no guaranteed money.
- He negotiated it himself.
It’s easy to conclude that those two factors are related, and suggest that Okung’s lack of an agent – and his lack of experience in contract negotiations – resulted in him agreeing to a team-friendly deal. That’s a point that’s hard to refute. Very few free agents who have signed contracts within the last week and a half have inked fully non-guaranteed deals — even minimum-salary players often receive guaranteed $80K signing bonuses.
Although he retained former NFL team cap analyst Jimmy Halsell, Okung was unable to talk to teams during the 52-hour legal tampering period before free agency officially begun. As many agents agreed to deals for their players during those two days, Okung was forced to wait, putting him behind the eight-ball from the start. Throw in the fact that he had never negotiated a contract for himself before, the odds of Okung landing a player-friendly deal weren’t great.
But just how unfavorable is Okung’s new deal? Let’s take a closer look. Based on various reports to date, here’s what the breakdown of the contract should look like:
2016:
- $1MM workout bonus
- $2MM base salary
- $2MM roster bonus if he spends one game on the 53-man roster
- Up to $3MM in playing-time incentives ($1.5MM for 80% of snaps, $3MM for 90% of snaps)
$1MM option that must be exercised before the first day of the 2017 league year. If exercised:
2017:
- $2MM base salary (fully guaranteed)
- $8MM roster bonus (fully guaranteed)
- Up to $1.5MM in per-game roster bonuses
2018:
- $9.5MM base salary (fully guaranteed)
- Up to $1.5MM in per-game roster bonuses
2019:
- $8.5MM base salary
- $2MM roster bonus
- Up to $1.5MM in per-game roster bonuses
2020:
- $9MM base salary
- $2MM roster bonus
- Up to $1.5MM in per-game roster bonuses
This breakdown may not be entirely comprehensive, but it’s a pretty close approximation of what Okung’s deal looks like, and it shows how significantly he’s betting on his health. In January, the longtime Seahawks lineman contacted teams to let them know he was undergoing surgery to repair his dislocated left shoulder, an injury he suffered during Seattle’s divisional-round loss to Carolina. Okung said in his message that he expected to be fully cleared in five months, which would put him on track to participate in training camp.
While Okung may be on track to fully participate in training camp, he likely won’t be healthy in time to do the same for offseason workouts this spring, which makes the $1MM workout bonus in his contract somewhat interesting. Injured players can still collect workout bonuses as long as they report for duty and participate in whatever activities they’re able to, so the only way Okung won’t earn that $1MM is if the Broncos are so discouraged by his recovery process that they cut him before – or during – their offseason workouts. The odds of that happening seem slim, unless Okung suffers a major setback in the next several weeks. If Denver was that concerned about his health, it’s unlikely the team would have signed him at all.
The real test for Okung will come in training camp and the preseason. If the Broncos don’t like what they see at that point, it would make sense for the team to cut its losses and avoid paying the left tackle $4MM in salary and bonus money. That total would become fully guaranteed if he’s on the roster for Week 1.
Being released during preseason roster cutdowns would probably represent the worst-case scenario for Okung on this deal. He’d only collect his $1MM workout bonus, and would be looking for work around the time when most teams already have their rosters set for the season. It’s possible – even likely – that there would be other teams desperate enough for a starting tackle that they’d roll the dice on Okung, despite Denver’s unwillingness to pay him, but he’d probably have to settle for a one-year deal at that point.
If that’s the worst-case scenario for Okung, what does the best-case scenario look like? Well, there’s a possibility that this deal could work out pretty well for him if he fully recovers from shoulder surgery and plays well in 2016.
Let’s say he makes the Broncos’ roster, and stays healthy all season, collecting an extra $3MM in incentives for playing 90% of Denver’s snaps. At that point, he’ll have earned $8MM in 2016, and the Broncos will be faced with a tough decision to make — do they commit to Okung for at least two more seasons, fully guaranteeing him another $20MM or so? If they choose to decline his option, he’ll have the opportunity to hit the market again, and a year removed from his shoulder injury, he could land a much better contract than he did in 2016.
Okung’s new deal certainly isn’t one of the most player-friendly agreements we’ve seen this month, but it’s not necessarily a total disaster. Considering he’s not even healthy at the moment, it’s not a huge surprise that Okung’s contract doesn’t look a little better. After all, Kelvin Beachum, another left tackle coming off a major injury (ACL tear in October), agreed to a similar contract with the Jaguars — it’s reportedly a one-year, $4.5MM deal with a four-year, $40MM option. The full details on Beachum’s pact haven’t been reported, and – unlike Okung’s – it probably includes some guaranteed money, but those guarantees are unlikely to be significant.
As was the case when he decided to hit the open market without an agent, Okung is betting on himself with this contract. In this case, he’s betting on his ability to get healthy and to return to his previous form. Given what we know about the 28-year-old’s injury history – he has never played a full 16-game season – it’s a move that could easily backfire, and won’t give him much of a security blanket if it does. If he has a strong 2016 season though, Okung will be in a position to earn a huge chunk of guaranteed money a year from now, when most of his fellow 2016 free agents will start to see the guarantees on their new contracts dwindling.
Photo courtesy of USA Today Sports Images.
2016 NFL Trades
Although the NFL isn’t typically considered a trade-happy league, that reputation has been earned due to a lack of major trade-deadline activity, and doesn’t necessarily tell the whole story. In the NFL’s offseasons, big-name players and early-round draft picks change hands with greater frequency, as trades serve as a key tool for teams looking to upgrade their rosters or accelerate a rebuild.
We’ve already seen plenty of trades consummated since the 2016 league year began on March 9th, and with the draft not too far off, several more deals figure to be completed this spring. We’ll track those moves – and the rest of the year’s trades, right up until the fall deadline – in this space. You can find this page, our 2016 NFL trade tracker, on our right-hand sidebar under the “PFR Features” menu at any time.
Here’s a breakdown of 2016’s trades to date, in reverse chronological order:
After Draft:
- Lions acquire CB Johnthan Banks.
- Buccaneers acquire a conditional 2018 seventh-round pick.
- Browns acquire LB Jamie Collins.
- Patriots acquire a conditional 2017 compensatory third-round pick.
- Broncos acquire TE A.J. Derby.
- Patriots acquire a 2017 fifth-round pick.
- Patriots acquire LB Kyle Van Noy and a 2017 seventh-round pick.
- Lions acquire a 2017 sixth-round pick.
- Packers acquire RB Knile Davis.
- Chiefs acquire a conditional 2018 seventh-round pick.
- Patriots acquire CB Eric Rowe.
- Eagles acquire a conditional 2018 fourth-round pick.
- Pick becomes third-rounder if Rowe plays 50% of snaps in either 2016 or 2017.
- 49ers acquire WR Rod Streater and a conditional 2019 seventh-round pick.
- Chiefs acquire a conditional 2019 seventh-round pick.
- Seahawks acquire S Dewey McDonald.
- Raiders acquire a conditional 2017 seventh-round pick.
- Vikings acquire QB Sam Bradford.
- Eagles acquire a 2017 first-round pick and a conditional 2018 fourth-round pick.
- Fourth-round pick becomes third-rounder if Vikings make NFC Championship Game, and becomes second-rounder if Vikings win Super Bowl.
- Cardinals acquire CB Marcus Cooper.
- Chiefs acquire a 2018 seventh-round pick.
- Bills acquire LB Lerentee McCray.
- Packers acquire a conditional 2018 seventh round pick.
- Saints acquire LB/DE Chris McCain.
- Dolphins acquire a conditional 2017 seventh-round pick.
- Panthers acquire P Andy Lee and a 2017 seventh-round pick.
- Browns acquire Kasey Redfern and a 2018 fourth-round pick.
- 49ers acquire WR Jeremy Kerley.
- Lions acquire OL Brandon Thomas.
- Chiefs acquire CB Kenneth Acker.
- 49ers acquire a 2018 seventh-round pick.
- Patriots acquire LB Barkevious Mingo.
- Browns acquire a 2017 fifth-round pick.
- Eagles acquire WR Dorial Green-Beckham.
- Titans acquire OL Dennis Kelly.
- Lions acquire LB Jon Bostic.
- Patriots acquire a conditional 2017 seventh-round pick.
During Draft:
- Browns acquire CB Jamar Taylor and a 2016 seventh-round pick (No. 250; LB Scooby Wright).
- Dolphins acquire a 2016 seventh-round pick (No. 223; QB Brandon Doughty).
- Vikings acquire a 2016 sixth-round pick (No. 188; TE David Morgan).
- Eagles acquire a 2016 sixth-round pick (No. 196; DB Blake Countess) and a 2016 seventh-round pick (No. 240; DE Alex McCalister).
- Dolphins acquire a 2016 sixth-round pick (No. 186; WR Jakeem Grant)
- Vikings acquire a 2016 sixth-round pick (No. 196) and a 2016 seventh-round pick (No. 227; LB Stephen Weatherly).
- Jets acquire a 2016 fifth-round pick (No. 158; T Brandon Shell).
- Washington acquires a 2017 fourth-round pick.
- Titans acquire a 2015 fifth-round pick (No. 157; CB LeShaun Sims) and a 2016 seventh-round pick (No. 253; DB Kalan Reed).
- Broncos acquire a 2016 sixth-round pick (No. 176; FB Andy Janovich) and a 2017 sixth-round pick.
- Seahawks acquire a 2016 fifth-round pick (No. 147; T Caleb Benenoch).
- Patriots acquire a 2016 seventh-round pick (No. 225; WR Devin Lucien) and a 2017 fourth-round pick.
- Patriots acquire a 2016 fifth-round pick (No. 147).
- Dolphins acquire two sixth-round picks (Nos. 196 and 204; DB Jordan Lucas) and a 2016 seventh-round pick (No. 250).
- Saints acquire a 2016 fourth-round pick (No. 120).
- Washington acquires a 2016 fifth-round pick (No. 152) and a 2017 fifth-round pick.
- Bears acquire a 2016 fourth-round pick (No. 113; LB Nick Kwiatkoski).
- Rams acquire a 2016 fourth-round pick (No. 117; WR Pharoh Cooper) and a 2016 sixth-round pick (No. 206; WR Mike Thomas).
- Raiders acquire a 2016 fourth-round pick (No. 100; QB Connor Cook).
- Browns acquire a 2016 fourth-round pick (No. 114; WR Ricardo Louis) and a 2016 fifth-round pick (No. 154; WR Jordan Payton).
- Dolphins acquire a 2016 third-round pick (No. 86; WR Leonte Carroo).
- Vikings acquire a 2016 sixth-round pick (No. 186), a 2017 third-round pick, and a 2017 fourth-round pick.
- 2017 fourth-rounder acquired by Vikings will be a compensatory pick if Dolphins receive one.
- Panthers acquire a 2016 third-round pick (No. 77; DB Daryl Worley) and a 2016 fifth-round pick (No. 141; CB Zack Sanchez).
- Browns acquire a 2016 third-round pick (No. 93; QB Cody Kessler), a 2016 fourth-round pick (No. 129; S Derrick Kindred), and a 2016 fifth-round pick (No. 168; OL Spencer Drango).
- Saints acquire a 2016 second-round pick (No. 61; S Vonn Bell).
- Patriots acquire a 2016 third-round pick (No. 78; OL Joe Thuney) and a 2016 fourth-round pick (No. 112; WR Malcolm Mitchell).
- Buccaneers acquire a 2016 second-round pick (No. 59; K Roberto Aguayo).
- Chiefs acquire a 2016 third-round pick (No. 74; DB KeiVarae Russell) and a 2016 fourth-round pick (No. 106; CB Eric Murray).
- Texans acquire a 2016 second-round pick (No. 50; C Nick Martin).
- Falcons acquire a 2016 second-round pick (No. 52; LB Deion Jones) and a 2016 sixth-round pick (No. 195; OL Wes Schweitzer).
- Seahawks acquire a 2016 second-round pick (No. 49; DT Jarran Reed).
- Bears acquire a 2016 second-round pick (No. 56; G Cody Whitehair) and a 2016 fourth-round pick (No. 124; DB Deon Bush).
- Packers acquire a 2016 second-round pick (No. 48; T Jason Spriggs).
- Colts acquire a 2016 second-round pick (No. 57; S T.J. Green), a 2016 fourth-round pick (No. 125; LB Antonio Morrison), and a 2016 seventh-round pick (No. 248; C Austin Blythe).
- Bills acquire a 2016 second-round pick (No. 41; LB Reggie Ragland).
- Bears acquire a 2016 second-round pick (No. 49), a 2016 fourth-round pick (No. 117), and a 2017 fourth-round pick.
- Dolphins acquire a 2016 second-round pick (No. 38; CB Xavien Howard).
- Ravens acquire a 2016 second-round pick (No. 42; DE/OLB Kamalei Correa) and a 2016 fourth-round pick (No. 107; WR Chris Moore).
- Jaguars acquire a 2016 second-round pick (No. 36; LB Myles Jack).
- Ravens acquire a 2016 second-round pick (No. 38) and a 2016 fifth-round pick (No. 146; DE Matt Judon).
- 49ers acquire a 2016 first-round pick (No. 28; G Joshua Garnett) and a 2016 seventh-round pick (No. 249; DB Prince Charles Iworah).
- Chiefs acquire a 2016 second-round pick (No. 37; DT Chris Jones), a 2016 fourth-round pick (No. 105; G Parker Ehinger), and a 2016 sixth-round pick (No. 178; CB D.J. White).
- Broncos acquire a 2016 first-round pick (No. 26; QB Paxton Lynch).
- Seahawks acquire a 2016 first-round pick (No. 31; T Germain Ifedi) and a 2016 third-round pick (No. 94; TE Nick Vannett).
- Texans acquire a 2016 first-round pick (No. 21: WR Will Fuller).
- Washington acquires a 2016 first-round pick (No. 22; WR Josh Doctson) and a 2017 sixth-round pick.
- Bears acquire a 2016 first-round pick (No. 9; OLB Leonard Floyd).
- Buccaneers acquire a 2016 first-round pick (No. 11; CB Vernon Hargreaves) and a 2016 fourth-round pick (No. 106).
- Titans acquire a 2016 first-round pick (No. 8; T Jack Conklin) and a 2016 sixth-round pick (No. 176).
- Browns acquire a 2016 first-round pick (No. 15; WR Corey Coleman), a 2016 third-round pick (No. 76; T Shon Coleman), and a 2017 third-round pick.
Pre-Draft:
- Eagles acquire a 2016 first-round pick (No. 2; QB Carson Wentz) and a 2017 fourth-round pick.
- Browns acquire a 2016 first-round pick (No. 8), a 2016 third-round pick (No. 77), a 2016 fourth-round pick (No. 100), a 2017 first-round pick, and a 2018 second-round pick.
- Rams acquire a 2016 first-round pick (No. 1; QB Jared Goff), a 2016 fourth-round pick (No. 113), and a 2016 sixth-round pick (No. 177; TE Temarrick Hemingway).
- Titans acquire a 2016 first-round pick (No. 15), two 2016 second-round picks (Nos. 43 and 45; DL Austin Johnson and RB Derrick Henry), a 2016 third-round pick (No. 76), a 2017 first-round pick, and a 2017 third-round pick.
- Rams will also acquire a 2017 seventh-round pick if they send their own 2017 third-rounder to the Titans, rather than a third-round comp pick.
- Jets acquire T Ryan Clady and a 2016 seventh-round pick (No. 235; P Lachlan Edwards).
- Broncos acquire a 2016 fifth-round pick (No. 157).
- Patriots acquire TE Martellus Bennett and a 2016 sixth-round pick (No. 204).
- Bears acquire a 2016 fourth-round pick (No. 127; DB Deiondre’ Hall).
- Cardinals acquire OLB Chandler Jones.
- Patriots acquire C/G Jonathan Cooper and a 2016 second-round pick (No. 61).
- Broncos acquire QB Mark Sanchez.
- Eagles acquire a conditional 2017 seventh-round pick.
- Titans acquire RB DeMarco Murray and a 2016 fourth-round pick (No. 113).
- Eagles acquire a 2016 fourth-round pick (No. 100).
- Dolphins acquire CB Byron Maxwell, LB Kiko Alonso, and a 2016 first-round pick (No. 13; T Laremy Tunsil).
- Eagles acquire a 2016 first-round pick (No. 8).
Where Things Stand In NFL Free Agency
Things move fast in NFL free agency, so it should come as no surprise that just five days after the new league year began, the majority of 2016’s top free agents have come off the board. Olivier Vernon, Malik Jackson, and Brock Osweiler – the first three players on our list of this year’s top 50 free agents – are among those that have signed new mega-deals already.
[RELATED: Full list of available free agents by position]
Our top 50 list was intended – at least in part – to predict which players would sign the biggest contracts of the offseason, and while we did pretty well at the top of our list, there were missteps further down. Our rankings appear to have underestimated the apprehension that teams would have for free agents with health questions. That’s why our No. 7 free agent, Jason Pierre-Paul, only managed a one-year deal, while others in our top 20, such as Russell Okung and Kelvin Beachum, remain unsigned.
Here’s a breakdown of the top 10 biggest deals signed so far, in terms of fully guaranteed money (per Over The Cap):
- Olivier Vernon, DE (Giants): Five years, $85MM. $40MM fully guaranteed.
- Brock Osweiler, QB (Texans): Four years, $72MM. $37MM fully guaranteed.
- Malik Jackson, DE (Jaguars): Six years, $85.5MM, $31.5MM fully guaranteed.
- Janoris Jenkins, CB (Giants): Five years, $62.5MM. $28.8MM fully guaranteed.
- Kelechi Osemele, G/T (Raiders): Five years, $58.5MM. $25.4MM fully guaranteed.
- Damon Harrison, DT (Giants): Five years, $46.2MM. $20MM fully guaranteed.
- Alex Mack, C (Falcons): Five years, $45MM. $20MM fully guaranteed.
- Brandon Brooks, G (Eagles): Five years, $40MM. $17MM fully guaranteed.
- Mark Barron, LB (Rams): Five years, $45MM. $15MM fully guaranteed.
- (tie) Sean Smith, CB (Raiders): Four years, $38MM. $15MM fully guaranteed.
(tie) Doug Martin, RB (Buccaneers): Five years, $35.7MM. $15MM fully guaranteed.
The Giants and Raiders dominate that list, combining for five players, and those two teams, plus the Jaguars, have been among the biggest free agent spenders so far.
In addition to their three signings noted above, the Giants also re-signed Pierre-Paul ($8.5MM fully guaranteed). The Raiders complemented their Osemele and Smith signings by adding Bruce Irvin ($14.5MM fully guaranteed). And the Jaguars landed Jackson, plus Tashaun Gipson ($12MM fully guaranteed), Chris Ivory ($10MM fully guaranteed), and Prince Amukamara ($3MM fully guaranteed).
Additional big spenders have included the Eagles (Brooks, Rodney McLeod, Chase Daniel), Texans (Osweiler, Lamar Miller, Jeff Allen), and Falcons (Mack, Mohamed Sanu).
While many of the big-name players have signed, there are still many players in our top 50 without deals. Some of these players, such as Eric Weddle, appear to be simply taking their time to weigh all their options, and could still land fairly lucrative deals. Others may not be generating as much interest as expected. Here’s a breakdown of those players:
- Russell Okung, T (11)
- Kelvin Beachum, T (15)
- Eric Weddle, S (17)
- Ryan Fitzpatrick, QB (19)
- Greg Hardy, DE (21)
- Donald Penn, T (26)
- Andre Smith, T (38)
- Reggie Nelson, S (41)
- Nick Fairley, DT (43)
- Rueben Randle, WR (49)
As our list of notable remaining free agents shows, the tackle market has been somewhat slow to develop. Okung and Beachum are both coming off injuries, Penn will turn 33 next month, and Smith isn’t a left tackle, so it makes some sense that there hasn’t been a ton of action on them, but I expect that will be one position that gains steam this week.
We should also see more movement at cornerback – which features players like Brandon Boykin, Leon Hall, and Patrick Robinson – and inside linebacker, where Zach Brown and James Laurinaitis are among the veterans available. You can find our complete, up-to-date list of available free agents right here.
This week’s action won’t be quite as fast-paced as last week’s, but things will still be busy, with teams continuing to focus on the second and third waves of free agency. After next week’s owner’s meetings, draft coverage steadily begins to dominate the NFL news cycle, but we’ve still got plenty of free agent signings to track before then, so check PFR frequently for the latest.
2016 Top 50 NFL Free Agents
2016’s NFL free agents can’t officially sign with any team except their own until March 9th at 3:00pm central time, but plenty of deals could be agreed upon in principle before then, with the league’s “legal tampering” window open on March 7th at 11:00am CT. Technically, teams and players aren’t permitted to finalize agreements on contracts during that legal tampering window, but that’s often treated as a guideline rather than a hard and fast rule.
Before all of this year’s best available players start flying off the board, we’ll take a look at the top players of the 2016 free agent class. Our list of 2016’s top 50 free agents doesn’t include restricted free agents, or players who were designated as franchise players, since they’re essentially restricted free agents now as well.
Earlier, we broke down the top free agents by position on both offense and defense, but our rankings below may not have each player listed in the same order. Those position lists took the short-term value of a player into account more heavily, meaning many players in their 30s received prominent placement. Our top 50 list favors longer-term value, and is more about forecasting which players will be in highest demand this week when it comes to years and dollars.
With those caveats out of the way, let’s dive right in! Here are Pro Football Rumors’ top 50 NFL free agents for 2016, along with a few predictions on how much they might earn and what teams could be in the mix to sign them:
Offseason Outlook: Denver Broncos
Pending free agents:
- C.J. Anderson, RB (RFA)
- Omar Bolden, CB
- Sam Brenner, C (ERFA)
- David Bruton, S
- Josh Bush, S
- Andre Caldwell, WR
- Todd Davis, LB (ERFA)
- Vernon Davis, TE
- Bennie Fowler, WR (ERFA)
- Ryan Harris, T
- Ronnie Hillman, RB
- Malik Jackson, DE
- Shiloh Keo, S (RFA)
- Brandon Marshall, ILB (RFA)
- Evan Mathis, G
- Lerentee McCray, OLB (RFA)
- Brandon McManus, K (ERFA)
- Jordan Norwood, WR
- Brock Osweiler, QB
- Matt Paradis, C (ERFA)
- Tyler Polumbus, T
- Antonio Smith, DE
- Danny Trevathan, ILB
- Kyle Williams, WR
Top 15 cap hits for 2016:
- Demaryius Thomas, WR: $15,200,000
- Von Miller, OLB: $14,129,000 (franchised)
- DeMarcus Ware, OLB: $11,666,668
- Ryan Clady, T: $10,100,000
- Aqib Talib, CB: $9,968,750
- Chris Harris Jr., CB: $9,000,000
- Derek Wolfe, DE: $6,800,000
- Louis Vasquez, G: $6,750,000
- Emmanuel Sanders, WR: $6,600,000
- T.J. Ward, S: $5,750,000
- Owen Daniels, TE: $4,500,000
- Britton Colquitt, P: $4,000,000
- Darian Stewart, S: $3,250,000
- Virgil Green, TE: $2,900,000
- Sylvester Williams, DT: $2,412,375
Notable coaching/front office moves:
- Football operations: Lost national scout John Spytek, who was hired by Buccaneers as director of player personnel.
Draft:
- No. 31 overall pick
- Owe fourth-round pick to Ravens in deal for C Gino Gradkowski.
- Acquired fifth-round pick from Ravens in deal for C Gino Gradkowski.
- Owe fifth-round pick to Lions in deal for OLB Shane Ray.
- Owe sixth-round pick to 49ers in deal for TE Vernon Davis.
- Acquired seventh-round pick from 49ers in deal for TE Vernon Davis.
- Acquired seventh-round pick from Texans in deal for T Chris Clark.
Other:
- Current projected cap room (via Over the Cap): $13.3MM
- Must exercise or decline fifth-year option for 2017 for DT Sylvester Williams.
- Assigned exclusive franchise tag to OLB Von Miller.
- QB Peyton Manning announced his retirement.
- Extended DE Derek Wolfe through 2019 season.
- Signed DT Phil Taylor.
Overview:
Enjoying one of the stranger routes to a Super Bowl title, the Broncos capitalized on the collection of talent they managed to fit under their salary cap. Despite teetering on the brink of potentially missing the playoffs after amassing a healthy early-season AFC West lead, the Broncos strung together three dominant defensive performances in the postseason once granted their fourth straight first-round bye. The 2010s Broncos are only the fourth team to do earn four straight byes in the double-bye era that began in 1990.
Oddly, this may have been the Broncos’ least complete roster since Peyton Manning arrived in Denver due to the 39-year-old quarterback’s steep decline and a makeshift offensive line. But the league’s top-ranked defense, which improved from a top-five-ranked unit to one in the conversation for best defense ever, compensated for the offense’s issues.
Residing alongside the 2000 Ravens, 2002 Buccaneers and 2013 Seahawks among the top Super Bowl-winning defenses from this century, the Broncos featured a similar outfit from the 2014 group that fell to the Colts in the divisional round. Only Darian Stewart was a new starter on the ’15 team, but Wade Phillips‘ arrival doubled as John Elway’s best offseason hire once it unleashed the talent the GM acquired on defense. Ranking No. 1 against the pass and No. 3 against the run, the Broncos made ball-advancement difficult throughout the season. Timely turnovers secured victories against the Ravens, Chiefs, Vikings, Raiders, Browns and Bengals, and the defense helped give an often-stagnant offense a wide safety net. The Broncos went 12-3 overall in games decided by seven points or less.
While his 3-4 scheme helped unleash Malik Jackson and Derek Wolfe as 5-technique ends, and moved Von Miller into the highest-paid defender discussion, Phillips proved malleable in key spots. The Broncos deviated from their blitz-heavy tendencies against the Patriots, yet still posted a staggering 23 quarterback hits to prevent New England from taking advantage of Denver’s conservative offense in the AFC championship game. Using more of a base defense in Super Bowl 50, the Broncos quickly stifled the Panthers’ vaunted zone-read attack and illuminated some weaknesses in Cam Newton‘s game that hadn’t surfaced much during the season.
Denver looks to return the bulk of this defense, one that saw five players — Miller, DeMarcus Ware, Shaquil Barrett, Jackson and Wolfe — register at least 5.5 sacks. The defense’s transition from Jack Del Rio‘s read-and-react approach forced quarterbacks into difficult decisions while managing to be a stout force against the run despite Terrance Knighton‘s departure.
The defense’s performance gave the Broncos’ offense plenty of time to work out issues, but ultimately, the unit settled into a game-managerial style that managed to score enough points while limiting turnovers. The Broncos finished plus-4 in the playoffs, but Manning’s and Brock Osweiler‘s 23 combined regular-season interceptions were the most in the league.
Denver’s offense shifted through several phases during its 19 games. An awkward Manning trying out Gary Kubiak‘s system soon gave way to a pistol-modified version, before Manning’s injury brought back Kubiak’s under-center play-action concepts during Osweiler’s starts. Upon return, Manning’s ball-control-based postseason approach proved reasonably effective, but it obviously looked foreign to those who followed the Hall-of-Fame passer’s career.
Denver finished with two 1,000-yard+ receivers for the fourth straight season, with Demaryius Thomas and Emmanuel Sanders repeating that feat. The departures of Julius Thomas and Wes Welker showed, however, with the Broncos’ auxiliary cast failing to make a steady impact. Denver’s run game also didn’t resemble Kubiak’s usual upper-echelon editions, ranking 17th at 107.4 yards per game. C.J. Anderson‘s early struggles burned fantasy owners and forced Ronnie Hillman into the starting role. Hillman dashed for a career-high 863 yards and seven scores before running out of steam and ceding work to Anderson down the stretch. Although Evan Mathis ranked as Pro Football Focus’ best run-blocking guard, Denver’s offense line took a step back, giving up 39 sacks. The Broncos yielded just 35 combined in 2013 and 2014.
Manning turned out to be worth the five-year, $96MM contract he signed in 2012, guiding the Broncos to 50 total wins and two Super Bowl appearances. His first two and a half seasons in Denver produced historic numbers and turned the Broncos into instant contenders after years of middling play in the Mile High City. Manning seemed to hit a wall midway through the 2014 season, causing the Broncos to become more reliant on their defense and ground game. But becoming the first quarterback to win Super Bowls with two different teams, lifting Denver to six home playoff games and breaking numerous passing records will make the Broncos nearly as relevant as the Colts as part of Manning’s legacy.
Manning transforming the Broncos into an instant powerhouse, and improving on his QB-record 11 12-win seasons, should rank alongside the work he did in Indianapolis in terms of the signal-caller’s stamp on the game.
Now that the Manning era is over, it will be interesting to see how the Broncos attempt to extend what’s been their most consistent period of dominance in team history. Should Miller sign a mega-extension, the defensive pieces are still largely in place. But the luxury of a quarterback providing coach-level knowledge and elite-level on-field work Denver enjoyed for the most part during this stretch won’t be there. Whether the Broncos can maintain will depend on what happens at quarterback.
Key Free Agents:
Obscured partially by odd off-field incidents and other players’ rises over the past few years, Von Miller re-emerged as the most feared outside pass rusher in football. Miller’s 11 sacks were actually the second-worst total of his career, but he maintained his lofty standing with the advanced-metrics community. Pro Football Focus rated Miller as its second-best edge defender behind Khalil Mack, but bestowed its best run-defending grade for edge-rushers on Miller.
Miller long
ago displayed his dominance in NFL circles but broke out on a national level during these playoffs.
Not factoring in much in the Broncos’ one-and-done postseason forays in 2012 or ’14, and not playing during Denver’s run to Super Bowl XLVIII due to a torn ACL, Miller turned in one of the league’s greatest playoff showings for a defender. His five sacks, two forced fumbles and an interception over the course of the Broncos’ final two wins illustrated his value. Predictably receiving the franchise tag, the soon-to-be 27-year-old Miller is the first player since Drew Brees to receive the exclusive tag for an impending free agent and the first non-quarterback to be protected in this manner since Richard Seymour in 2007.
Miller’s Broncos talks may be more complicated than the ones that resulted in franchise players Ryan Clady, Matt Prater and Demaryius Thomas being signed in July of 2012, 2013 and 2015, respectively. The star pass rusher appears to be campaigning for Ndamukong Suh-type money (six years, $114MM, $59MM guaranteed), but the Dolphins were paying Suh in comparison to what he could make on the open market after the Lions didn’t tag him. With Miller being tagged for $14.13MM, the Broncos can use that as leverage in an effort to keep Miller’s price under those marks. Still, Miller will surpass Justin Houston‘s league-high linebacker contract of six years and $101MM and be a part of the Broncos’ title defense this season. John Elway‘s track record for signing his top players points to Miller being back on a long-term accord, even though the negotiations could be tricky.
Elway’s talks with Osweiler may have progressed to the point where the ball’s in the court of Peyton Manning‘s longtime apprentice. The Broncos have reportedly offered the 6-foot-8 quarterback a $45MM deal over three years, which surpasses Nick Foles‘ prove-it-type pact with the Rams but falls just shy of the $16MM AAV threshold that poses a figurative line of demarcation for franchise quarterbacks. Sam Bradford‘s deal and Kirk Cousins‘ franchise tag may have increased Osweiler’s value. The 25-year-old comes in No. 1 on PFR’s list of available signal-callers, and it would behoove Osweiler to see what his market is before re-signing in Denver.
Osweiler may be able to earn more money with a team like the Texans, who aren’t in position to draft Jared Goff or Carson Wentz. But his odds of playing out a contract and staying on track to earn an accord in line with top-flight quarterbacks may be best with the Broncos. After going 5-2 as a starter in a strong late-season audition, Osweiler re-signing with Denver would place him back in a system he seems to fit and give him the luxury of operating with a top-tier defense. Should Osweiler sign elsewhere, he wouldn’t necessarily have these amenities and would have to go about learning a new offense. Osweiler may prove not to be worth the money in an environment that forces him to be more of a gunslinger and less of a game manager.
We don’t yet know what kind of guarantees the Broncos are offering, and that could be the delay in Osweiler re-signing. The former second-round pick surveying the market could induce Denver to up the price. Even though Elway has been one of the best GMs in the game in signing players to team-friendly deals, he might cave at the thought of Osweiler leaving and the Broncos having to turn to a journeyman or a rookie to guide his defending champion roster.
Signing Osweiler to a deal that either nears or exceeds $15MM annually, however, based on seven starts would qualify as Elway’s biggest risk as a GM. Osweiler’s 61.8% completion rate and 10-to-6 TD/INT ratio were positive marks based on his limited work in previous low-stakes situations, and the Broncos don’t win a title without his contributions. But Denver’s offense struggled to get first downs during several entire halves under Osweiler, whose ceiling is certainly in question.
A deal for Osweiler that’s only a few million per year shy of Manning’s lucrative salaries will make it difficult to keep Malik Jackson. The burgeoning-star defender has reportedly rebuffed eight-figure-per-season offers from the Broncos and seems likely to hit the market, where teams with more money and in greater need of pass-rushing help await. The reported deal close to $11MM AAV the Broncos offered Jackson would place the fifth-year player in close proximity to the highest-paid 3-4 ends who are not named J.J. Watt.
Jackson, however, has thrived at three different positions over the past three years – 4-3 defensive tackle in 2013, 4-3 end in ’14 and (most notably) 3-4 end under Wade Phillips – and could push for interior pass-rushing money in line with the 4-3 tackles that aren’t Ndamukong Suh. Although the 26-year-old Jackson outworked Gerald McCoy ($15.9MM AAV) and Marcell Dareus ($16.1MM per year) in terms of combined sacks, hits and hurries last year, he probably won’t receive an offer quite that lucrative. Anything in that realm and the Broncos — who already signed Jackson’s 2012 draft classmate, Derek Wolfe, to a four-year, $36.7MM deal — may have to let someone else pay Jackson’s second contract.
Danny Trevathan
, however, profiles as the kind of player Elway has let leave. He allowed Wesley Woodyard to exit after 2013 and hasn’t paid the kind of money Trevathan is probably seeking to non-rush linebackers. The only deal of consequence the Broncos have given to an inside backer under Elway’s watch came when the team extended Joe Mays for $4MM per year in 2012, and John Fox benched Mays less than halfway into that season.
Trevathan looks to have a higher ceiling than Woodyard, who signed for four years and $16MM with the Titans in 2014. Despite playing his first season as an inside ‘backer, Trevathan led the Broncos in tackles for the second time and showed teams he has sufficiently recovered from the leg injuries that derailed his 2014 campaign. The former sixth-round pick could conceivably fetch more than $7MM from a linebacker-needy team. Twelve inside ‘backers earn that on average, and Trevathan is younger than most of them. Entering only his age-26 season, Trevathan ranks as PFR’s top inside linebacker UFA and, unlike Jackson, the Broncos haven’t made much of an attempt to keep him off the market.
Ronnie Hillman is a more intriguing case. He stood out for the Broncos in his fourth year and is only 24. Entering the draft after his sophomore season at San Diego State, Hillman is younger than his free agent ball-carrying brethren, but he clearly ranks among the second tier of UFA backs – behind the likes of Doug Martin, Lamar Miller, Matt Forte and possibly a few others – and may not command too much more than the $770K he earned in 2015. Should Hillman’s market dry out, a return to Denver looms plausible.
Hillman did not show well in the playoffs, rushing for just 54 yards compared to C.J. Anderson‘s 234. And despite his profile as a change-of-pace ball-carrier, Hillman didn’t factor into the Broncos’ passing game — the former third-round pick caught just 24 passes for just 111 yards. It’s more likely that the Broncos let someone else give Hillman a slight raise and either team Anderson with Juwan Thompson and a mid-round rookie next season, or select Anderson’s potential successor in the early rounds.
The Broncos’ free agent gridlock includes two starting linemen, Evan Mathis and Ryan Harris. Neither figures to rank too high on the club’s offseason itinerary.
Mathis graded as the best offensive lineman in the Super Bowl for either team, per Pro Football Focus, and proved to be another pivotal signing by the Broncos. Coming to Denver for one year and $4MM, Mathis battled multiple maladies to lead Denver’s three-guard rotation. He’s hinted at retirement and will turn 35 in November. It’s possible Mathis will continue his career and sign a new contract, but with Max Garcia likely to step in at one of Denver’s guard spots, the veteran likely won’t get that new contract from the Broncos.
An emergency signing once Ryan Clady tore his ACL during OTAs, Harris was thrust into the role of left tackle after Ty Sambrailo also was lost for the season. Harris and Michael Schofield doubled as one of the worst tackle tandems in football, according to PFF, however. The 30-year-old Harris could have a route back to Denver, where he has had two stints, but only as a swing tackle on a veteran-minimum-type contract.
Possible Cap Casualties:
The Broncos’ tightrope walk in an effort to keep Brock Osweiler and Malik Jackson could result in some high-profile names being cut.
Ryan Clady has already agreed to discuss a pay reduction, and the Broncos are in talks with their longtime left tackle about doing so. But how much of a salary slash the 29-year-old Clady will accept is uncertain, and so is his future performance level after missing 30 regular-season games — and both Super Bowls in which the team appeared — the past two years. A former two-time first-team All-Pro and a player drafted to block in a zone system identical to the one Gary Kubiak utilizes, Clady is probably a better option than most tackles available. But the Broncos could save $8.9MM by releasing him, a route John Elway likely will consider despite the Broncos’ issues at the position. Clady has two years remaining on the five-year, $52.5MM extension he signed four years ago.
Louis Vasquez resides in a similar place. Injuries nagged the former first-team All-Pro, and he lost snaps to Max Garcia in the Broncos’ guard shuffle. Although Vasquez played most of the snaps in the playoffs, he’s entering the final saeson of his four-year contract. The Broncos can save $5.5MM by cutting their right guard. As is the case with Clady though, they don’t have an in-house replacement.
One of these performers could well receive the ax, with DeMarcus Ware‘s lofty cap figure ($11.67MM) looming as one the Broncos would probably like to reduce but only ditch as a last-resort measure. Ware delivered more quarterback hits in the playoffs than Miller despite recording 3.5 sacks to Miller’s five. The Broncos may not have qualified for the Super Bowl had Ware not torched Sebastian Vollmer in the AFC title game, showing no ill-effects from the back injury that forced him to miss a career-most five games during the regular season.
Ware, however, will be 34 and the Broncos sport pass-rushing depth. Shaquil Barrett stood out as Ware’s primary replacement, collecting 7.5 sacks. The ex-UDFA could team with 2015 first-rounder Shane Ray to help the Broncos compensate for a Ware release. However, neither can match Ware’s explosiveness, and a scenario where the Broncos lose Ware and Manning in one week may be a lot to digest for a defending champion whose roster reveres those presences. The Broncos can save $10MM by jettisoning Ware.
Positions Of Need:
If the Broncos can’t reach an agreement with Brock Osweiler this week, their options dwindle fast, especially if the Jets retain Ryan Fitzpatrick. Chase Daniel and Matt Moore are the proven backup options, with potentially available higher-risk players like Colin Kaepernick and Robert Griffin III not yet officially available. The latter duo at their respective peaks would represent upgrades over Osweiler, but both come with significant baggage and aren’t the offensive caretakers Osweiler and the postseason version of Peyton Manning proved to be. Kaepernick may require the Broncos to surrender as much as a second-round pick as well.
Rookie prospects like Connor Cook or Dak Prescott may be contingency plans in case Osweiler does receive a monster offer and the Broncos need to sign a veteran backup. Manning’s workmanlike playoff outings proved the Broncos didn’t need stellar quarterback play to win, but their defense might not be quite as good if certain UFAs bolt. And having to go with a rookie learning from a veteran like Moore or even Tarvaris Jackson would potentially be a steep downgrade from Osweiler.
The Broncos’ overtures to Osweiler make it likely he returns, but if John Elway believes preserving this defense supersedes employing a highly-paid quarterback, it will be a very interesting offseason for the defending champions. Only one eventual Super Bowl champion in the free agency era has allowed its starting quarterback to defect via free agency – the Ravens upon replacing Trent Dilfer with Elvis Grbac – so there’s not a lot of precedent for what could transpire in Denver if its Manning succession plan backfires.
Denver’s offensive line will need reinforcements regardless of how Elway handles Louis Vasquez and Ryan Clady. Pro Football Focus ranked the Broncos’ front 20th last season, and the group’s top-rated performer, Evan Mathis, isn’t expected to be back. The Broncos probably turn to Matt Paradis and Max Garcia at two spots, with likely one of Clady and Vasquez occupying a third and Ty Sambrailo expected back at one of the tackle positions. But Sambrailo didn’t perform well in his brief debut, so adding a tackle should be a priority. Clady is a short-term solution at this point.
The bulk of the UFA tackles are power-blocking players, and with the salary crunch in which the Broncos find themselves, a high-priced player is presumably off the table. Texas Tech’s Le’Raven Clark or Indiana’s Jason Spriggs may be available when the Broncos pick at No. 31, and this figures to be an early-round need. Elway, however, hasn’t been big on drafting for need, exemplified first by his bypassing Patrick Peterson and Marcell Dareus for Von Miller, then the best-player-available tendencies surfacing again the past two years. In 2014, the Broncos drafted Bradley Roby after already having Aqib Talib and Chris Harris in the fold, and last year traded up to pick Shane Ray to play behind Miller and DeMarcus Ware.
Guard is also a need, and there are some UFA candidates. Former Gary Kubiak charges in Houston, Brandon Brooks and Ben Jones, make sense. Both Kubiak-drafted players began their careers as zone-blockers and possess extensive seasoning as starters. Brooks and Jones started at least 10 games in a season under Kubiak during his Texans tenure, and each has been a Houston starter the past two years. Before moving to center, Jones played guard under Kubiak.
Pro Football
Focus hasn’t enjoyed Zane Beadles‘ work in Denver or Jacksonville, but the recently released guard has proven durable in being healthy for every game of his six-year career. Denver would be able to sign him for less than what the Jaguars paid to bring in the now-29-year-old interior man. Guard is a position the Broncos will also likely address in the draft. They haven’t taken a guard or tackle in the draft’s first two rounds since using a second-rounder on Orlando Franklin in 2011.
Should Jackson depart, the Broncos could save money by shifting Vance Walker to end and acquiring depth. Walker played end with the Chiefs and functioned well as a reserve tackle/end last season in Denver. PFF ranked Walker as its No. 27 interior defender, and he’s due back with the Broncos on a $1.5MM salary in 2016. Mike DeVito is one of the many UFAs that could depart Kansas City and won’t cost as much as Jaye Howard. DeVito had a decent season, but the Chiefs’ well-fortified front didn’t have room for him. Cedric Thornton did well for himself in his contract year, but possibly too well. There aren’t a lot of players who fit Jackson’s description; his replacement will be cheaper and almost certainly inferior.
Running back and inside linebacker qualify as needs, but the Broncos are unlikely to allocate much capital toward filling them, even though some mock drafts have the team going for Derrick Henry in Round 1. With C.J. Anderson‘s postseason work sample showing he’s a starting-caliber back, the Broncos need a player who can complement him by being a receiving threat instead of someone who has a similar skill set. Utah’s Devontae Booker (622 receiving yards in two seasons) or Louisiana Tech’s Kenneth Dixon (464 air yards, seven touchdown receptions in 2015) make more sense as a second- or third-round pick to supplement Anderson and potentially take over once Denver’s current starter’s contract expires after 2016.
Todd Davis looms as the top in-house option to succeed Trevathan. The Broncos, in all likelihood, won’t spend much more than a mid- or late-round pick here and almost certainly won’t bring in a pricey veteran.
Extension Candidates/Contract Issues:
Signed to what turned out to be a steal at three years and $15MM, Emmanuel Sanders enters a contract year in 2016. Gary Kubiak‘s offense traditionally funnels through its No. 1 receiver, as Rod Smith and Andre Johnson have shown, but Sanders has arguably been better than Demaryius Thomas the past two seasons at a fraction of the cost. This proved true in the playoffs, when Sanders served as Peyton Manning‘s top weapon in hauling in 16 passes for 230 yards compared to Thomas’ 7/60 line.
Entering his age-29 season this fall, Sanders could see his worth escalate a year from now. Assuming Alshon Jeffery and the Bears come to an agreement, Sanders could be the top receiver on the 2017 market prior to cuts being made, especially if the Texans extend DeAndre Hopkins or exercise his fifth-year option. Doug Baldwin and Michael Floyd are the other prominent 2017 UFAs as of now. Sanders’ versatility to line up outside and in the slot should put him in line for a final big payday.
To sign Sanders, the Broncos will need to up his price somewhat. If their now-conservative offense looks a lot like what it displayed in 2015, securing Sanders’ early-30s services might not be a high priority at the price he could command. After all, Thomas currently represents the team’s largest cap hold at $15.2MM in ’16. However, unlike this year, the Broncos don’t look to have a deep crop of departing UFAs, which could spark interest in retaining their No. 2 target.
Sylvester Williams‘ third season was largely overlooked due to the abundance of talent around him. The Broncos’ nose tackle proved serviceable in his first year without Terrance Knighton but came off the field on most passing downs due to Malik Jackson and Derek Wolfe‘s abilities at creating inside rushes. With Jackson perhaps on his way out of Denver, the Broncos may opt for some security on its front without much depth behind Wolfe and Williams.
The Broncos could keep Williams around for two more seasons, with his 2017 option costing them at least $6.15MM, and move on after his first contract expires. Williams entered the league in time for his age-25 season, and if the Broncos pick up his option, he’ll turn 30 during the first season of his next contract. The 27-year-old provides stability now, but barring an uptick in play, Williams may see age affect his earnings down the road.
Denver’s 2013 draft class wasn’t strong. Only Williams and third-rounder Kayvon Webster remain on the team, but Brandon Marshall looms as a de facto ’13 pick due to his rookie-year practice squad time delaying his NFL clock. Marshall, a restricted free agent due to receive a second-round tender from the Broncos, is on track to be a UFA next year and could have a similar market to Trevathan. A former Jaguars fifth-round pick, Marshall being back this season will make it easier for the Broncos to cut ties with Trevathan. But losing both of their No. 1 defense’s starting inside linebackers in two years would put an emphasis on adding at this spot in the draft.
If the Broncos don’t address the ILB position in the draft this year, they could attempt to lock up Marshall early for around $5MM-$6MM per season. The 26-year-old Marshall’s eventual asking price may depend on what Trevathan receives this week. With players like DeMarcus Ware, Louis Vasquez and possibly Ryan Clady and Aqib Talib (the latter due $32MM in non-guaranteed money for his age-31, 32 and 33 seasons) coming off the books, extending someone like Marshall may prove to be important.
Overall Outlook:
While it will be difficult to duplicate what the Peyton Manning years brought, the Broncos are well-positioned in the short-term. John Elway‘s ability to sign outside talent, keep his top players and unearth gems in the late rounds and via UDFA signings have his team looking like the favorite to win the AFC West for a sixth straight season.
Their defensive capabilities notwithstanding, the Broncos’ viability as a long-term contender will come down to Brock Osweiler‘s development if he re-signs. If Osweiler builds on his late-season work, the Broncos’ title window can potentially extend longer than expected. If the league adjusts to the thus-far middling talent, it’s hard to place the defending champions among the favorites to challenge teams like the Patriots or Steelers for conference supremacy.
Information from Over The Cap was used in the creation of this post. Photos courtesy of USA Today Sports Images.
Top 2016 Free Agents By Position: Defense
NFL free agency will get underway on Wednesday, March 9th, and while we can still expect the list of free agents to undergo some major changes between now and then, we’ll head into free agency week with a pretty good idea of what the market will look like. Franchise and transition tags have been assigned, many teams have cut their overpriced veterans, and most clubs are in the process of assigning RFA and ERFA tenders, if they haven’t already done so.
With free agency around the corner, it’s time for us to break down the outlook for each position. After looking at offense yesterday, we’ll tackle defense and special teams today.
Listed below are our rankings for the top 15 free agents at each defensive position. These rankings aren’t necessarily determined by the value of the contracts – or the amount of guaranteed money – that each player is expected to land in free agency. These are simply the players we like the most at each position, with both short- and long-term value taken into account.
Restricted and exclusive-rights free agents, as well as players who received the franchise tag, aren’t listed here, since the roadblocks in place to hinder another team from actually acquiring most of those players prevent them from being true free agents.
We’ll almost certainly be higher or lower on some free agents than you are, so feel free to weigh in below in our comments section to let us know which players we’ve got wrong.
Here’s our breakdown of the current top 15 free agents by defensive position for 2016:
Interior defensive line:
- Malik Jackson
- Damon Harrison
- Ian Williams
- Jaye Howard
- Nick Fairley
- Cedric Thornton
- Haloti Ngata
- Akiem Hicks
- Terrance Knighton
- Mike DeVito
- Brandon Mebane
- Paul Soliai
- B.J. Raji
- Jared Crick
- Steve McLendon
Honorable mention: Kevin Williams, Al Woods, Ahtyba Rubin, Randy Starks, Henry Melton
The interior of the defensive line might be the deepest positional class among the defensive free agent groupings, but the list is clearly led by Malik Jackson, who looks poised to cash in on the open market after the Broncos were forced to use their franchise tag on another defender, linebacker Von Miller. At just 26 years old, Jackson figures to be among the highest-paid of this year’s free agents, at any position.
Clubs that play a 3-4 scheme will be especially interested in this crop of free agents, as Ian Williams, Jaye Howard, Cedric Thornton, and Haloti Ngata are all extremely experienced in that front (and offer some degree of positional flexibility). On the 4-3 side, Nick Fairley, who had to settle for a one-year contract last offseason, figures to interest teams looking for gap-shooting interior lineman.
Nose tackle also features a multitude of options, and although Damon Harrison is expected to land the largest deal, Terrance Knighton, Paul Soliai, and B.J. Raji should also be able to find nice contracts in the coming weeks. All four of those players are adept at plugging up space in the middle, although the latter three may be forced to take short-term pacts due to either age or recent performance.
Edge defender:
- Olivier Vernon
- Bruce Irvin
- Jason Pierre-Paul
- Mario Williams
- Charles Johnson
- Greg Hardy
- Tamba Hali
- Robert Ayers
- William Hayes
- Derrick Shelby
- Nick Perry
- Junior Galette
- Jason Jones
- Chris Long
- O’Brien Schofield
Honorable mention: Adrian Clayborn, Courtney Upshaw, Mike Neal, Dwight Freeney, Andre Branch
While we didn’t include franchise-tagged players on this list, we did incorporate Olivier Vernon, who was assigned the transition tag by the Dolphins. Miami will have the option to match any offer receives from another club, but they won’t receive any compensation if they decline to match. The latest reports indicate that the Dolphins could simply allow Vernon to walk if he signs an offer sheet that pays him more yearly than the transition tag will ($12.734MM).
Elsewhere, Bruce Irvin seems ready to earn more than $10MM annually, and given that he’s not expected back in Seattle, the Jaguars and Falcons — both of whom employ former Seahawks coordinators as head coaches — make sense as landing spots. Jason Pierre-Paul will face an interesting free agency due to the status of his injured hand, as will Greg Hardy and Junior Galette due to off-field concerns, and in the case of Galette, Washington’s right to match any offer he receives.
Clubs looking for veteran pass-rushers are in luck this offseason, as Mario Williams, Charles Johnson, and Chris Long — all recently released — join longtime Chief Tamba Hali as free agents. Of the group, Long had the worst season in 2015 and might have to sit on the open market for awhile longer, but the other three should find a robust market for their services — Williams and Johnson, in fact, have already begun taking visits with interested teams.
Inside linebacker:
- Danny Trevathan
- Jerrell Freeman
- Rolando McClain
- Derrick Johnson
- Zach Brown
- Stephen Tulloch
- James Laurinaitis
- Demario Davis
- Craig Robertson
- Daryl Smith
- Erin Henderson
- Donald Butler
- Mason Foster
- DeMeco Ryans
- Keenan Robinson
Honorable mention: Kelvin Sheppard, Jasper Brinkley, Audie Cole
After helping the Broncos to the Super Bowl title last season, Danny Trevathan figures to be the highest-paid among free agent inside linebackers. A return to Denver is possible, but with their cap problems, the Broncos will probably have to bow out — the Falcons, for one, have been mentioned as a possible destination for Trevathan.
Veteran presence abounds on this list, as James Laurinaitis, Daryl Smith, and DeMeco Ryans have all been recently released by their respective clubs. Laurinaitis will probably be the most coveted of the trio, as Smith reportedly might head back to Baltimore on a cheaper deal, while Ryans has dealt with so many injuries in recent seasons that it might be hard for him to land a starting gig.
As far as projects go, Zach Brown might be my favorite of the bunch — the former second-round pick is full of athleticism, but just never broke through with the Titans, so a change of scenery could do him good. Further down the list, Craig Robertson has shown an aptitude for pass coverage, a trait that is highly coveted in today’s NFL.
Outside linebacker (non-rush):
- Tahir Whitehead
- Mark Barron
- Vincent Rey
- Nigel Bradham
- Chad Greenway
- Sean Weatherspoon
- Danny Lansanah
- Justin Durant
- Bruce Carter
- Emmanuel Lamur
- Shea McClellin
- David Hawthorne
- Philip Wheeler
- Spencer Paysinger
- Jason Trusnik
Easily the weakest group among the defensive free agent class, it was a struggle to find 15 players to fit this list. Indeed, it might be considered a stretch to call several of these players outside linebackers — Sean Weatherspoon, Bruce Carter, Shea McClellin, and David Hawthorne all have recent experience on the inside.
Tahir Whitehead looks like the clear favorite to sign the biggest deal among this group, but Mark Barron might be the most interesting player on the list. Drafted No. 7 overall as a safety, Barron looked like a bust until he was traded to the Rams, who converted him to weakside ‘backer. He’s thrived ever since, and it seems like Los Angeles wants to retain him.
The tail end of this list features linebackers whose primary role will be on special teams, but closer to the top, Vincent Rey and Nigel Bradham would fit in most systems — not as stars, certainly, but as role players who can be counted on. Chad Greenway also offers that level of veteran experience, but it’s likely that he’ll stay in Minnesota.
Cornerback:
- Janoris Jenkins
- Sean Smith
- Prince Amukamara
- Casey Hayward
- Adam Jones
- Brandon Boykin
- Jeremy Lane
- Leon Hall
- Patrick Robinson
- Nolan Carroll
- Josh Robinson
- Jerraud Powers
- Antonio Cromartie
- Shareece Wright
- William Gay
Honorable mention: Sterling Moore, Charles Tillman, Kyle Wilson, Coty Sensabaugh, Terence Newman
Janoris Jenkins will probably get the most money among free agent corners — he’s 27, and he already reportedly turned town $9MM per year from the Rams. Los Angeles placed the franchise tag on fellow CB Trumaine Johnson, so it’s unclear if Jenkins is still in the club’s plans.
He’s a year older, but Sean Smith could give Jenkins a run for his money as the highest-paid free agent corner, and I wouldn’t be shocked if he ultimately earns more. Smith probably isn’t the pure athlete that Jenkins is, but he’s arguably more steady, and that’s something teams will pay for in a corner.
The group of slot corners might be the most interesting part of this list, as Brandon Boykin, Jeremy Lane, and Leon Hall all stand to earn a bit of money from the inside. Casey Hayward, too, has been primarily deployed on the inside, but he’s shown an ability to play outside cornerback as well, so he should be in line for a larger deal.
Safety:
- George Iloka
- Eric Weddle
- Rodney McLeod
- Tashaun Gipson
- Reggie Nelson
- Walter Thurmond
- Rashad Johnson
- Dwight Lowery
- Isa Abdul-Quddus
- Husain Abdullah
- Tyvon Branch
- David Bruton
- Robert Golden
- Will Allen
- Michael Griffin
Honorable mention: Chris Conte, James Ihedigbo, William Moore, Quintin Demps, Roman Harper
Like the interior defensive line class above, the safety group contains a strong list of players who could be counted on to start for a number of clubs. The Bengals, notably, will see both their starting safeties hit the open market — Reggie Nelson led the league in interceptions and made the Pro Bowl last season, but George Iloka is seven years younger, so he’ll score the bigger deal.
After nine years in San Diego, Eric Weddle has stressed that he’ll look to latch on with a contender this offseason, and he shouldn’t be wanting for suitors. Tashuan Gipson also expects to move on from his old club — the Browns — and like Iloka, his age should help him land a nice contract. Rodney McLeod, also young at just 25, probably isn’t a household name, but he has been excellent during his career with the Rams, and his next deal could surprise.
Isa Abdul-Quddus and David Bruton haven’t been full-time starters during their careers, but they’ve been solid when they’ve been asked to play. Meanwhile, Chiefs free agents Tyvon Branch and Husain Abdullah weren’t asked to start last season — Eric Berry and Ron Parker held down those roles, but there’s little doubt they could handle a starting job.
Kicker:
- Adam Vinatieri
- Josh Brown
- Greg Zuerlein
- Nick Novak
- Phil Dawson
- Kai Forbath
- Randy Bullock
- Shayne Graham
Justin Tucker would have easily topped this list of free agent kickers, but he has already signed his franchise tender with the Ravens. Adam Vinatieri is still going strong at age 43 and is expected to return to the Colts, so Josh Brown, who shined with the Giants last year, might the best kicker to actually reach the market.
Greg Zuerlein (aka “Greg the Leg”) has the best distance on his kicks, but has struggled with accuracy — the Rams have indicated he won’t be handed the kicking job if he returns, so maybe he heads elsewhere.
Punter:
Like at kicker, the best player at punter — the Raiders’ Marquette King — has already been taken off the market, and none of these players are likely to land a large deal. Of the bunch, Bryan Anger will probably make the most money, as he’s a former third-round pick and is only 27 years old.
Luke Adams contributed to this post. Photos courtesy of USA Today Sports Images.











