Opinion: McAfee Retirement Leaves Void
- Punters don’t typically get a lot of credit for what they do, but Pat McAfee‘s retirement leaves a significant void for the Colts to fill, Mike Wells of ESPN.com writes. For his career, McAfee averaged 46.4 gross yards per punt and 39.8 net yards per punt. He also had 33.6% of his 575 punt attempts land inside the 20.
Colts Punter Pat McAfee Retires
One of the most colorful personalities in the game is calling it quits. Punter Pat McAfee announced early Thursday morning that he is walking away from the sport after eight years in the NFL. 
In a lengthy farewell letter posted to Twitter, McAfee said that he spoke with Colts owner Jim Irsay at length about his future this week and although Irsay wanted him to continue playing, he is supportive of his decision. The charismatic punter says he will now join Barstool Sports full-time as a personality while continuing to live in Indianapolis.
From a talent standpoint, McAfee feels that he could have continued punting for “a few more years,” but he wasn’t sure if he could continue to boot balls at a high level with his attention split between different interests. McAfee, 29, leaves the game with two Pro Bowl selections and a highlight reel full of memorable celebrations, including his Conor McGregor strut. We wish McAfee the best in retirement.
Colts Notes: Draft, Thomas, Allen
- Is Stanford’s Solomon Thomas a fit for the Colts? In his latest mailbag, Kevin Bowen of Colts.com says that he is intriguing after a strong season, but it remains to be seen whether teams view him as a good 3-4 edge fit. Right now, Thomas is widely projected to fall between Nos. 7-to-15 in the first round. The Colts own the No. 14 overall pick.
- What’s first on the agenda of new Colts GM Chris Ballard? Bowen notes that exploring new deals for free agents like Mike Adams, Darius Butler, Jack Doyle, Robert Turbin, and Erik Walden will be at the top of his list. Allen is wrapping up a team-friendly two-year, $4.3MM contract and after grading out as a top-20 safety according to Pro Football Focus, he’s in line for a significant pay bump.
Colts Notes: Ballard, Raye, Pagano
- Newly minted Colts GM Chris Ballard received a five-year contract, according to Mike Chappell of FOX59. Colts vice president of football operations Jimmy Raye III was among the candidates Ballard beat out for the role, and owner Jim Irsay revealed Raye nearly got the job, per Stephen Holder of the Indianapolis Star. Irsay assured Raye, who will remain in the Colts’ Ballard-led front office, that someone else will give him a shot as a GM if the Colts orchestrate a turnaround (all Twitter links here).
- While Ballard reportedly isn’t committed to going forward with Chuck Pagano beyond the 2017 season, he spoke glowingly of the five-year head coaching veteran Monday. “There were no other options. Chuck Pagano is a great coach,” said Ballard (Twitter link via Holder). Upon Ballard’s hiring, Pagano stated Sunday that he’s “extremely excited” to work with the rookie GM (via the Colts’ Twitter account).
Ballard Plans To Re-Evaluate HC Spot In 2018
As Jim Irsay said upon firing Ryan Grigson, Chuck Pagano will return to coach the Colts in 2017. New GM Chris Ballard will stick to that plan, but he’s not committed to the coach longer than that, Adam Schefter of ESPN.com tweets. Ballard intends to keep Pagano in 2017 but is planning to re-evaluate the position before the ’18 season.
The new executive’s hire may only intensify the hot seat for Pagano, who expressed his support (Twitter link) for the 47-year-old Ballard upon his hire. Irsay appears set to oversee an arranged marriage between his top two decision-makers after letting both Grigson and Pagano start together in 2012. Pagano led the Colts to three playoff berths, one of which involving a historic comeback win over the Chiefs in Ballard’s first year in Kansas City, before the team stumbled to back-to-back 8-8 seasons. We heard over the weekend Ballard could have Chiefs special teams coordinator Dave Toub as a possible replacement come 2018.
- Ballard’s knowledge of the draft represents a good fit for a Colts team that’s struggled identifying amateur talent since its strong haul of 2012, Mike Wells of ESPN.com writes. In addition to the talents Ballard played a part in the Bears procuring during his time in Chicago, the Chiefs dispatched their then-director of football operations to investigate then-embattled prospect Marcus Peters, Adam Teicher of ESPN.com notes. Teicher pegged Ballard, whom he called the No. 3 man in Kansas City’s power structure behind John Dorsey and Andy Reid, as a potential Dorsey successor.
Colts Hire Chris Ballard As GM
The Colts moved quickly to land their man, hiring Chris Ballard as their new general manager, the team announced. Previously the Chiefs’ director of football operations, Ballard was the only candidate to interview with the Colts twice out of the six-man search.
Ballard met with the Colts a second time on Sunday and will succeed Ryan Grigson, beating out Packers executive Eliot Wolf, Vikings assistant GM George Paton, Seahawks co-player personnel directors Trent Kirchner and Scott Fitterer and internal candidate Jimmy Raye III, who served as the Colts’ interim GM during this process.
The newly hired executive is planning a 2017 season with Chuck Pagano, Ian Rapoport of NFL.com tweets, so there will be no late coaching change after Jim Irsay orchestrated a belated GM switch.
Viewed as Irsay’s top choice from the start of this process, Ballard opted to go through with the interview. He did not interview for the 49ers’ GM job, which remains unfilled, since the Chiefs blocked him from doing so. Teams can utilize this tactic during the season, but with Kansas City having been eliminated in the divisional round, Ballard was free to interview with Indianapolis. However, Ballard was viewed as the “first choice, second choice and third choice” in San Francisco.
The Chiefs’ decision may be a seminal move depending on what happens with the Colts and 49ers in the next several years. Although, the Colts’ job was viewed an attraction, more so than the 49ers’ position, with Andrew Luck‘s presence playing a key role.
Prior to becoming John Dorsey‘s right-hand man in Kansas City, Ballard spent 12 seasons with the Bears, working in either a scouting or scouting directorial capacity. The Chiefs’ 43 regular-season wins since 2013 came on the heels of a 2-14 2012 season under the franchise’s previous regime and represent the fourth-most in the league during that span.
His potential top choice for head coach could be Chiefs special teams coordinator Dave Toub, although Irsay committed to Pagano coaching the team in 2017. Pagano sat in on the candidate interviews, Mike Garafolo of NFL.com reported, so a Ballard/Pagano partnership looks like the Colts’ arrangement this coming season. Ballard will be tasked with elevating the franchise back to the playoffs after it finished 2016 with the same 8-8 record 2015 brought, with ’16 featuring nearly a full season’s worth of Luck’s services.
Chris Ballard Books Second Colts Interview
The buzz surrounding Chris Ballard as Ryan Grigson‘s potential successor looks legitimate. The Chiefs’ director of football operations became the first candidate to secure a second interview with the Colts, Adam Schefter of ESPN.com tweets. This could be a quick process, per Schefter, who reports (on Twitter) the Chiefs are bracing to lose Ballard to the Colts. The second summit is set for Sunday.
The four-year Chiefs executive was part of a six-person interview contingent that met with Colts brass from Wednesday-Friday in Mobile, Ala. As Albert Breer of TheMMQB.com tweets, Ballard did not disappoint in that interview, and it appears as if he will, in fact, be offered the position. Per Breer, Ballard was the Colts’ top choice all along, although that of course conflicts with earlier reports tabbing interim GM Jimmy Raye III as the favorite for the job.
But Ballard and Packers exec Eliot Wolf emerged as the early favorites once the club began interviewing outside candidates, and rumblings of the Colts being “definitely intrigued by” John Dorsey‘s top lieutenant — and Ballard’s preferring Chiefs special teams coordinator Dave Toub as his head coach — emerged yesterday. Ballard, Wolf and George Paton — whose interview reportedly went well — came away with positive reviews from the Colts’ meeting process thus far.
Despite the fact that Ballard would like to bring in Toub as his head coach, Jason La Canfora of CBS Sports says that Ballard’s having to work with Chuck Pagano — who will reportedly return for the 2017 campaign — will not be a deal-breaker. Instead, if the team is looking for a new head coach next offseason, the Colts could simply pursue Toub at that time (Twitter links).
After spending 12 seasons with the Bears in a scouting or scouting directorial capacity, Ballard has helped oversee a Chiefs resurgence in the mid-2010s. Only the Patriots, Seahawks and Broncos have more regular-season wins than the Chiefs’ 43 since 2013. Kansas City could be set to lose Ballard but will be retaining Dorsey for at least one more season after a report emerged Dorsey is in fact under contract through 2017.
The Chiefs blocked Ballard from interviewing with the 49ers but could not do so when the Colts’ GM job opened because league rules only enable this practice during the team’s season.
Colts Considering Ballard/Toub Partnership?
While the Colts aren’t expected to rush in their pursuit to fill their GM position, positive reviews continue to surround one candidate. The Colts are “definitely intrigued by” Chiefs director of football operations Chris Ballard, Jason La Canfora of CBS Sports tweets. And that could be an interesting development because of Ballard’s ties to a recent head coaching candidate.
Ballard’s preferred choice as HC would be Chiefs special teams coordinator Dave Toub, per La Canfora. That is a logical pairing, but the Colts are not currently in the market for a head coach. Jim Irsay reaffirmed his commitment to Chuck Pagano and is prepared to bring him back for a sixth season. Pagano’s seat, though, would be arguably the hottest in the NFL going into 2017 after consecutive 8-8 seasons helped end the Pagano/Ryan Grigson partnership.
Ballard and Packers player operations director Eliot Wolf are considered the favorites for the Indianapolis GM position, a status interim GM Jimmy Raye III occupied last weekend before the official interviews commenced. The Colts met with all six of the candidates between Wednesday and Friday.
Irsay’s been connected to multiple head coaches this offseason, and while the owner said his conversations with ESPN analyst Jon Gruden were merely about the stete of his team, Sean Payton trade rumors also surfaced recently. The Colts said the call came from a Payton associate rather than being an Irsay-initiated process. Hiring a GM who has a coach preference not currently employed by the franchise would add to the uncertainty surrounding Pagano. Recently, much of Pagano’s staff received word they are going to remain in their positions for at least one more year.
The 54-year-old Toub interviewed for the Chargers’ and Broncos’ HC positions, being one of just three coaches Denver considered for its since-filled vacancy. Ballard and Toub have worked in Kansas City since John Dorsey‘s hire in 2013.
Latest On Colts’ General Manager Search
The Colts aren’t rushing through their hunt for a new general manager, and have identified “no specific timetable” during which they will make a decision on their next personnel chief, according to Stephen Holder of the Indianapolis Star. The process isn’t expected to reach a conclusion for at least another week to 10 days, tweets Mike Garafolo of NFL.com.
[RELATED: 2017 GM Search Tracker]
Indianapolis and owner Jim Irsay finished up its first round of interviews, and follow-up meetings are to be scheduled, per Holder. Chiefs director of player personnel Chris Ballard and Packers director of football operations Eliot Wolf are considered the favorites for the position, reports Jason Cole of Bleacher Report (video link), although incumbent candidate Jimmy Raye III — currently acting as the Colts’ interim GM — has also been mentioned as the leader in the clubhouse.
The six contenders — a list that includes the Seahawks’ Scott Fitterer and Trent Kirchner, the Vikings’ George Paton, and those listed above — are meeting with Indianapolis head coach Chuck Pagano as part of the interview exercise, tweets Garafolo, rightly noting that the “dynamic” between Pagano and the next general manager will be critical. The mandatory retaining of Pagano is a small barrier for some candidates, per Holder, but the vacancy is still viewed as highly attractive.
“What a great situation,” one of six contenders anonymously told Holder. “But you’ve got to fix that defense. It’s old.”
George Paton Willing To Take Colts' GM Job
- Vikings assistant general manager George Paton‘s interview with the GM-needy Colts went “extremely well,” sources told Chris Hagan of FOX 59 (Twitter links). Paton has turned down as many as 10 opportunities to leave Minnesota’s front office in recent years, but he’d finally be willing to depart if the Colts were to offer him their GM job, according to Hagan. Of course, Paton’s also in the running for the GM role in San Francisco, where he’s a finalist for the position.